The Babysitter and the Sisterly Trio/ChapterIX/Too Horny

I try to fall back asleep, but it's not going well...

With Evy lying across my chest, Tera hugging my left arm tightly like it was a teddy bear, and Riley pressing the length of her body against my right side, my erection only got harder. Soon it was all I could think about!

After a few minutes of silence, Riley whispers in my ear.

"Um, hey Rei? Are you asleep..?"

I turn my head to face her and whisper back. "Not really. Is something on your mind?"

She nods her head. "You were right, we could have gotten caught. I don't want anyone or anything to get between us! I.. I love you..!"

A tear rolls down her cheek. I gently cup her face in my hand and gently brush the tear aside with my thumb.

"I don't want that, either. I love you girls so much! We just have to be more careful, alright?"

"Yeah..." Riley mumbles.

We stare into each others eyes for a few minutes, not needing words to express how we feel about each other. Finally I pat Riley on the head and take my hand off her face. Closing my eyes, I try once again to go back to sleep...

...Barely a minute or two later, Riley's voice jolts me back from the verge of sleep. "I still can't sleep, Rei..." she whispers.

I sigh, peeling back one eyelid to peer at her. "Why not?" I ask her, waiting patiently.

"I'm... umm... I can't stop thinking about... you know..."

I turn my head and look at her. I raise one eyebrow, and she blushes.

"I f-feel... warm.. down b-between my legs. I wanna d-do it again..!"

Heh. So she's still horny, too? Maybe we can help each other with that...

"Err, I didn't want to say anything cuz you guys were so tired, but, uh..."

Fortunately for my sake, Riley was a pretty sharp girl.

"Haah.. You too, huh?" She reaches her hand down to my groin and bumps the massive flagpole sticking up out of my pants. "Eeep!" she squeaks, my dick twitching as she touches it.

"S-So, umm... C-Can we h-have sex again..?" she asks, timidly.

"Alright, but I don't want to wake Tera and Evy." Having a great idea, I smile broadly and wink at her.. "So.. that means you're going to have to do most of the work this time, okay?"

She looks at me confusedly. "Wh-What do you mean?"

"Well, normally I'm the one moving my hips when we have sex, right? Well this time you're gonna have to do it." I explain to her, trying to think of a good analogy. "Have you ever ridden a horse or pony before?"

"A couple of times, at the fair." she replies, a curious look on her small face.

I grin at her. "Well, you know how you bounce up and down as the horse trots? That's basically what you're gonna do. Just imagine my penis is an trotting horse and bounce your hips up and down on it."

Riley's brown furrows. "I think I get what you mean..."

"Well then, go ahead. Just try not to make too much noise. Though I think it take would a lot to wake these two up right now, heh."

"Okay!~" she replies with a grin of her own.

I gently move Evy off my chest and lie her next to me where Riley just was. Meanwhile, Riley slips off her pajama bottoms and sets them gently on the dresser beside the bed.

Next, she helps me pull my own pants down to my ankles and climbs on top of me, straddling my hips with her legs like my body was a horse's saddle.

"Excellent. Now grab my penis and line it up with your pussy."

Riley timidly grabs ahold of my dick and tries to line it up with her little pussy. She's a bit clumsy at first, but eventually gets the head pressed up against her little slit.

"N-Now what?" she asks me, her voice catching. Just the stimulation of having the head of my penis pressed against her vagina was making her pant.

"Now, let your legs slide apart and your body fall. Gravity should do the rest!~"

Riley swallows, still a bit unsure of herself. "Ookay... H-Here goes..!"

She does what I said and lets her hips sink, gasping as my dick parts her little slit and slowly begins invading her preadolescent womb.

Riley closes her eyes and her lip trembles as she sinks down slowly, eventually taking my entire length inside of her. The sensation is incredible, and there's something very, very satisfying about teaching her how to ride me!

"Good job!~" I tell her, gently rubbing her forehead with my free hand.

"W-What do I d-do now?" she asks, already panting and moaning. I still can't believe any of these girls can take my entire length inside of them, but Riley did it with relative ease!

"Now you gotta start moving." I explain to her. "Lift your hips back up and then push them down again. Imagine you're sucking on my dick, except this time with your pussy instead of your mouth. Bob up and down. You can go as fast or slow as you want - you're in control this time!~"

"O-Okay!~" she mutters. Riley begins bobbing her pelvis on my dick, her hips gyrating as she moves her groin up and down. My dick slides out of her little cunny about half way before she lets her hips fall again.

"Good girl!" I ruffle her hair. "You've got this! Keep going!~"

Riley grins. She beings going fast, her confidence growing with each bounce. Soon she's moving much faster, and raising herself up even higher before slamming back down.

Soon after, she orgasms. Her back arches and she lets out THE most adorable little moan, but she doesn't stop riding me. Instead, she starts slamming her lil' cunt down on my dick even harder, her butt twitching so adorably that I have the urge to reach down and squeeze it (so I do just that).

Wanting to give her a little assistance, I use the hand on her ass to help her push down, forcing my dick deep inside her preteen cunny before pulling it back out again. Riley orgasms again, and this time I can even feel her convulsions myself.

"I-I love y-you, R-Rei!" she moans.

"I love you, too, Riley!~" I moan back. "Your l-little p-pussy is squeezing my dick so tightly!" I gasp.

"Haaahhhh... Does it f-feel good?" she demands. "D-Do you like feeling your d-dick inside a little girl's p-pussy?"

"Y-Yes! Your insides feel incredibly!" I cry out, squeezing her butt tightly. "I want to c-cum inside of you!"

"Mmmmh!! Yes!!! P-Please c-cum inside my little p-pussy, Rei!~" she cries. "I wanna f-feel you squirt y-your stuff in my b-belly!~"

At this point, Riley's going all out. She bucks on my cock like she was a bull tamer at a rodeo! Shuddering, she cums again, not slowing down in the slightest.

"Th-Then push h-harder!" I cry. "I'm.. almost... THERE..!!~"

I move my hand from her butt to grip her tightly around the waist. Slamming her down HARD onto my dick, I flood her tiny womb with my seed. Riley collapses against my chest, continuing to buck her hips as my dick convulses inside of her, spraying her insides full of hot, thick semen.

Seeing her little body twitching all pressed up against mine gives me so much pleasure. I ride out my own orgasm, lost in pleasure. I can feel her hot breath on my skin as she tries to catch her breath. Her own heart is racing so hard that I can feel it beating against my chest!

Reaching down, I slide my fingers around Riley's cum-sickened pussy and find her little clit. I massage it as she continues bucking her well-speared pussy on my dick, and Riley cums one final time...

We lie pressed together like that for quite some time, until I realize that Riley had passed out from what could only be described as an ecstasy overload. Grunting, I grip her little body one handed and pull her off my dick with a wet sloshing sound. I can feel out combined bodily fluids leaking out of her little cunny and dripping onto my groin.

I hug Riley's adorably little body to my chest and she continues to twitch and moan every few seconds. When she finally stops, I hear her breathing stabilize and she sighs.

Remembering this time to redress us before going back to sleep, I try to shake Tera off my other arm so I can do it easier. She won't let go of her death-grip around my arm, though. Tera gripped my arm so hard that I swear I remember it being numb in the morning!

It takes some real effort to wipe Riley down, put her pants back on, and pull my own pants back up, but somehow I manage it.

Afterwards, I lie awake for a while longer with Riley sleeping softly against my chest, Tera locked to my arm, and Evy dozing peacefully pressed up again my other side.

I ponder how lucky I am, to have these three adorable little girls love me as much as I love them. I never thought I'd find love in my life, given my.. interests. Hell, I'd never even dated anyone before! Is this what it feels like to be truly happy...?

I lie awake for a bit longer, thinking. Eventually, I drift off into peaceful slumber of my own.

I have some very nice, very lewd dreams to finish off the night with...

Later that morning...