Offline/Try to think of something your cousins have done
"Never have I ever gone skiing."
Nicole raises her hand quietly to signal that she has. Jet nods as well, but Hannah pokes her boyfriend.
"You don't ski, you snowboard! Don't give it to him that easy."
"Oh. Sure," Jet shrugs. "I don't ski."
Nicole also pulls back. "I thought you said skating," she clarifies.
"Come on! Really?" you exclaim in frustration. "Snowboarding is skiing!" You huff and groan, knowing that whiffing like this puts you in their crosshairs. Maybe it's a blessing in disguise. You don't have to be given a bad dare, right?
"Oh Jay! Did you fuck up? It sure looks like it!" Crap. Harley Quinn is back. "Aww, and you probably knew how much Jet loves the slopes and tried to use that to your advantage! Poor Jay. You're just desperate to get another taste of pussy, aren't you? Actually..." Hannah ponders aloud. "You totally can! I know what your dare should be... you have to lick my boyfriend!"
Your eyes dart to Jet, then down to his slimy cock. "Woah! What? No way!"
Hannah waves her hands to de-escalate. "Hear me out! You don't know the next time someone is going to dare you to do something, right? Maybe it's next turn, maybe it's never again. But... you're a virgin right?"
Are you? Technically it went inside Nicole. "Um, yeah, bu-"
"So wouldn't it be crazy to find out what a girl's pussy tastes like? What she tastes like when she's really horny?"
"Oh my god..." mutters Nicole, bringing a hand to her face to again bring attention to her own embarrassment.
"Well then just dare me to lick Nicole!" you suggest, causing Nicole to raise her other hand.
"That's no fun at all!" Okay, Hannah is definitely not on your side. You've also lost your erection. Maybe you shouldn't have grabbed her pussy earlier. "And this is supposed to be about having fun! Isn't it?" she continues. "It's not like I'm telling you to suck him. It's just licking. Let's say for... 30 seconds."
"For 30... Screw that! One lick is too many!"
"Wait! Hold on." She again pulls your energy down. "Super easy. What about... 10 licks? Base to tip?"
You ponder that a moment. Why are you entertaining this? How is her logic convincing you? Hannah is so persistent. Jet thinks this is hilarious. Nicole is still lying to herself that this is all a game. But with your luck this might be the closest you'll ever get to eating out Nicole. The idea of tasting your own cousi-
"Oh, he's totally gonna do it," mutters Jet aloud with amusement.
"5 licks," you counter, your resolve waning.
"8, final offer. Or I'll make you blow him for a whole minute."
You're about to ask Jet or Nicole to step in and suggest something else, but Nicole hasn't felt inclined to say anything so far and Jet seems more than happy to see this happen so they aren't likely to back you up. Your desire to taste Nicole ends up overpowering your disgust.
"Shit, Jay. You're my new favorite cousin! Or you're about to be." Jet slides his way forward until he's in the middle of the room. He's holding his cock from below, his fingers wrapped beneath his ballsack to push it higher into the air. His balls glisten just as much as his shaft does. What have you just agreed to?
You didn't really think about the 'how' but it's unfortunate that Jet doesn't want to stand. He doesn't want to lay down either. Maybe he wants to watch you do it. But with him sitting on the floor there's really only one way you can reach him to do this. You sprawl out onto your stomach and come face to face with Jet's monster as soon as you're prone. He's even more intimidating when his junk is so close to your eyes. How does Hannah blow this thing?
"I thought you were going to lick it, not admire it," jabs Hannah.
You hadn't intended on admiring Jet's cock. If anything you're just a little dumbfounded by how huge it is. But you don't bother replying to Hannah, you just commit. You shoot your tongue at the base of towering dick before you, your chin hitting his balls, and pull your head back quickly to lay a speedy stroke up his length. Hannah 'woo's mid-lick which spurs you on.
During your second lick it really hits you that you're lapping up Nicole's virginal pussy juice, a weird tangy sort of flavor with an aftertaste of every taboo imaginable. That makes your third lick longer, your own dick stiffening as you scrape your way up the towering length of Jet's cock to collect as much of Nicole onto your tongue as you can. Unfortunately by your fifth lick it tastes less like Nicole and more like straight cock. It just tastes like skin to be fair, but you want more of Nicky. Because of this you lay some short licks sideways over Jet's slickened balls, his sack still coated in the stuff you're after, and end up smearing some of Nicole across your face. But you make as quick work of all this as you can.
"Wait, wait, wait," grumbles Hannah as you pull away. "You never even gave one full lick! I said base to tip, but you avoided his head every time!"
"I did 8 licks," you note, wiping your chin. "That's good enough."
"I don't think so!" argues Hannah. "You spent so much time licking his nuts that I lost my count! So you for sure owe two more proper licks. Or instead, if you want you can kiss his tip... for two seconds. Up to you."
You swear you counted each lick but Hannah is just so pushy and insistent about everything. Jet doesn't comment, he just smiles and slowly twirls his dick in the air. Wanting it to be over, you lean forward and plant a chaste smooch on the tip of his cock. Your lips instantly slip off with how slick his tip also is and you move your head trying to follow it. You really hope that slickness is all from Nicole. But you had also hoped you wouldn't get yourself hard from licking cock, yet you're easily as stiff as Jet now.
"Jay! Mmm! Going for it!" praises Hannah after you count two of your own Mississippi's. "I'd make you my favorite again but I think Naughty Nicky is bound to steal it away! Gotta admit you've inspired me though." Hannah straightens up and waits for you and Jet to be seated again before revealing, "Never have I ever... tasted another girl's pussy."
Jet is quick to admit he has and is a little bit proud of this fact. You instantly realize that you just joined your older cousin in the weirdest way possible, licking one cousin off of the other. But Nicole is having her own realization. You can see it on her face as she's connecting the dots without anyone's help about which of Hannah's fingers she ended up sucking. Of course Hannah knows all of this already, that's why she said it, but for once she's not grinning like crazy. She's weirdly stoic.
"Huh, I guess you all lose again, don't you? Well that's okay. You're gonna win in a second," she sings, glancing at you and Jet. "I think Naughty Nicky proved she isn't gay, though I'm not sure about Jay now," she adds with a teasing lick of the air. "But I still think Nicole needs one more test." Hannah crawls to the side and runs her hand over Jet's torso, dragging her fingers over his lean stomach and smiling down at his cock. She then turns to Nicole very matter-of-factly. "I want to see my boyfriend inside you."
Nicole's eyes open wide. "What? You want me to hav-"
"All I want," interrupts Hannah, "is to see him inside you. I want to know exactly how much of this mean cock can fit inside your teenie little pussy. That's all. I'm not saying you have to 'have sex' or anything like that. Just put it in. You have to try to get as much inside you as you can." She slides her hand down his pelvis to the base of his cock, just bumping up against it. "I can get all the way down to here if I'm really trying. And I'm betting you can't."
Nicole is still blushing from before but now she's fiddling with herself too, absently parting her pussy. With how willingly she was grinding on Jet's cock a few minutes ago you're pretty sure she's okay with this idea, whatever she might be telling herself. She still can't break all the way through her shyness to admit that out loud. Ultimately that has to be why she wanted to come out here in the first place; to try to take part in the sexcapades you kept talking about. She isn't ever going to admit to that of course.
"Okay, but... he's my cousin."
"Yeah, okay, you keep pretending that matters. Here's the facts: We're all horny as shit. You've already had his D all over you. Now I want to see it in you. If you don't want to try, that's fine. We can just stop all this." Hannah gingerly grabs Jet's dick and flops it around a little. "Although... maybe I could change my mind. Maybe I give a dare to Jet instead. And maybe I tell him to fuck someone... and not me..." He's already plenty hard, but her encouragement causes him to grin and shake his head.
"You know you're twisted af, right?" he asks.
Hannah stretches upward toward Jet. "Yeah, I know that." She shares a sultry kiss with him while teasing his cock, then pulls away before whispering, "And that's why you like me."
"Okay, but..." Nicole starts, trying to reason this out. "I just... I don't know about this. It seems wro..." Nicole trails off, not able to complete that thought before latching onto another. "You... you really want this? You really want my cous- er, your boyfriend to cheat on you?"
"No! Of course not! This isn't a relationship, Nicky! It's not even real sex! It's more like... like trying on a shoe. I just want you to try it. See how he fits." Hannah turns toward Nicole, her expression going flat. "Unless you're into rape." She leaves her man's side and slinks on all fours the few steps it takes to close the distance with her target, staring into Nicole's eyes menacingly from mere inches away.
"So, if you want to have sex, you can lay down and get your pussy fucked..." Hannah runs her hand up Nicky's thigh. "And I will make him fuck you. Or... you can just have some more fun! But either way I'm going to see what that monster looks like inside your preppy little girly-girl snatch. But if you somehow manage to entertain me and my boyfriend, maybe we'll let you test fit your boyfriend later."
Nicole glances over at you then turns her head away. "Jay's not my boyfriend," she murmurs.
"Yeah, whatever," replies Hannah, dismissing Nicole's comment, muttering, "And I'm a virgin."
This is so wild. Nicole doesn't seem all that bothered by Hannah's threats. Maybe she's confident that Jet would never do that to her. You're not so sure about that given how this night has gone. It's also strange that Nicole hasn't just peaced out with how serious Hannah has gotten all of a sudden. Does Nicole still think this is all just a game? If true, she really doesn't know when to quit. But if she does want to get fucked she isn't willing to say it. You'd never have thought you would want to see Nicole get all the way freaky with your cousin Jet, but like Hannah you'd love to see her try to take his cock monster.