IV/4
Chapter 4
Olivia had woken up, from hearing Matthew when he was punched, so she came out, and saw the three just outside the pool. She quickly got beside Matthew, realized he was alive, and started doing CPR on him. After a few minutes, she put her mouth on his, and blew in. She moved back to pushing up and down on his chest for a few minutes, then moved back to his mouth.
He came back to life while she was kissing him, and he coughed water out of himself, and into her mouth. She broke the kiss, spat it out, then went back to kissing him, for sexual reasons this time, and he put his hands on the back of her head, keeping her close for the kiss.
After a minute or so, he broke the kiss, by pushing her off of him, and looked around. At this point, Alice had also woken up, so they were all there beside him. "What happened?" Olivia asked to anybody who was willing to answer.
"I- umm..." Natalie started, but looked down, "I tried to kill him... and he would have been gone... like mommy and daddy... and-" She started crying and ran into the house, nobody followed her, they just let her go.
Matthew sat up, he was hard again, after seeing everyone naked, and he wanted to fuck one of them. "I'll go talk to her." Matthew said and stood up, they were gonna follow him, but he said, "Alone." So they stayed behind, as he went inside the house.
The three of them went into the pool, because there was no reason not to. Matthew searched the house for Natalie, and found her hiding in the attic, crying in a corner, he didn't even know she knew how to get into an attic before that.
He sat beside her, and she looked up, "Hey, it's ok, I know it wasn't on purpose." He said.
"But it was! I purposefully kicked you in the back of the head, trying to hurt you!" She said, and starting crying more, she tried to stand up to leave, but Matthew held her back.
Matthew enjoyed hurting her earlier, and decided to take advantage of the fact that she nearly killed him. "Well, if you did it on purpose, then I am gonna punish you for it." He said and she looked down, ready to take whatever punishment he had in store for her, feeling she deserved it.
"You are gonna be my slave for the rest of your life, you will do whatever I tell you, no matter what." He said, and smiled, then went back down and out to the back porch with Natalie following close behind.
Olivia swam to the edge of the pool, and Matthew spoke to her, "Because she nearly took my life, I am taking hers, she is my slave for the rest of her life." He said it loud enough for the other two to hear, and they were more fascinated than anything else.
Olivia knew he was doing it so he could have sex with her, without her trying to get away, because she knew Natalie was uncomfortable around him. "You can't do this." She whispered to Matthew, "You are gonna destroy her emotionally, if you make her your slave, it will constantly remind her of today." Matthew just shrugged, and ignored her comment, she couldn't really do anything to stop him.
Natalie was standing beside Matthew, with her head down, looking at the ground. "You all are allowed to wear clothes again, including you, Natalie." He said, she was definitely the most excited about this, and she jumped up and down in place.
All three girls in the water stayed naked, and Matthew turned to Natalie, who wanted to put something on, now. "Go put on the shortest skirt you have here, and nothing else." He said, and she bolted inside, not hearing that last part in here haste.
She came back wearing her shortest skirt, which barely went past her crotch, but she also wore panties and a t shirt. Matthew forcefully removed her shirt, "I said only the skirt." He said, and slapped her across the face, then removed her panties.
"I-I'm sorry!" She said through tears, "I didn't hear that..." She didn't want to make him mad, she wanted him to be happy with her.
"Next time, stay until I finish telling you what to do." He said, and slapped her again. Olivia saw how rough he was being with her, but couldn't do much to help her. He kicked her in the pussy, and she fell to her knees crying, "Stand up." He ordered.
She slowly stood up, and he kicked her again, and she went down with a loud cry. "Stand up." He ordered, and she stood back up, but it hurt her just to stand. He kicked her again, and when he told her to stand back up, she couldn't.
"I said stand up!" He said, knowing she wasn't able to, and then rolled her onto her back. He spread her legs, then kicked her again in the crotch, wanting her to hurt as much as possible before he did what he did next.
"Keep quiet." He ordered her, as he got above her, and lined himself up with her already hurt pussy. She put both her hands onto her mouth to stay quiet, then he shoved his dick into her as fast and deep as he could in a pussy so small.
Olivia was watching the whole thing, she found herself getting turned on by seeing her little sister being raped. She started masturbating under the water as Matthew fucked Natalie as hard as physically possible. Alice and Lilly were also watching, but they felt bad for Natalie, and wanted him to stop, but didn't do anything, because they didn't know if there was anything they really could do.
Natalie had her hands tight on her mouth, trying to silence what would be screams from the pain. Matthew showed her no mercy, fucking her as hard as he could, causing her to bleed. When he finally finished in her, he pulled out, and blood mixed with cum came dripping out of her pussy.
He stood up, and she stayed on the ground, but removed her hands from her mouth. "Stand up." Matthew said, but she didn't even try to, knowing she wouldn't be able to succeed. "Stand!" He ordered, and when she didn't, he went inside, then came back out with a belt.
"Stand up!" He ordered one more time, she tried to get up, but she was in too much pain, and quickly gave up. He whipped her with his belt, "I am gonna keep whipping you until you stand up!" He said, she cried, and felt bad for not being able to satisfy him.
He whipped her for fifteen minutes until he got bored, and tossed her into the pool. She couldn't swim back up to the surface, so Olivia grabbed her and brought her up. Matthew jumped into the pool, and then slapped Natalie, while Olivia was holding her.
"You are the worst slave ever, you can't even follow my orders!" He growled, Olivia wanted to defend her sister, but thought better of it, it would probably do more harm than good. "I am gonna make you regret not obeying me!" He said and slammed his foot into her pussy, the blood was dried at this point.
Matthew started whipping Natalie again, she had her mouth covered in an attempt to be quiet. She wanted to make Matthew happy with her, but she couldn't get up, no matter how hard she tried. Matthew was making her feel like this on purpose, making sure she would be submissive.
Olivia after having a few orgasms while watching them, decided to do something about it. She got out of the pool, and stood in the way of Matthew, but he was already in motion to whip Natalie, so Olivia got whipped hard, but on the head, because of where she stood.
She cried out and fell backwards onto Natalie, who lost all her air when Olivia made contact with her. Olivia tried to get up, but as if she wasn't there, Matthew tried to whip Natalie again, but as Olivia was standing up, it hit her, again on the head.
She gasped and fell to her knees, fighting the pain. Matthew kicked her in the crotch, "Get out from in front of my slave!" He was mad, and kicked her again in the crotch, but this just made her unable to get out of the way.
When she tried to stand up and leave, she just fell onto her back beside Natalie. Matthew slammed his foot into Olivia's face, knocking her out, and turned to the people in the pool, "Don't come between me and my slave." He warned, and none of them tried, fearing a similar punishment to what happened to Olivia.
Matthew got an idea on how to mess with Natalie's emotions quite a bit. He stood above her, and looked down at her face, "You were there... you saw something!" He accused, just making it up, to make her go back to that day, and get all emotional, "What did you see? Describe it to me." He said.
She took a minute to start talking, she was actually going to describe how the crash happened. When she did, it was clearly not easy, she was in pain, but also very sensitive to the topic. When she was just about to start, Matthew got impatient, "Hello? Speak!" He ordered.
"Umm... M-mommy and daddy, umm, were arguing... and w-" She started, but was interrupted.
"What were they arguing about?" He didn't know how perfect this question was for him, because she completely broke down when he said it. She curled into a ball and started crying, without saying another word. "Speak!" He ordered, and she slowly uncurled herself, and prepared to speak.
"They... They-" She paused and put her head in her hands, and continued, making sure her mouth was uncovered. "They were arguing... about... about... m-me..." She said and paused for a second, "Then... I... I tried to stop them from arguing... I put my arm between them, and they both stared at it, but continued arguing."
"Then... neither of them... were looking... a-at, the r-road..." She started, and looked up at Matthew, "They, were... l-looking at... me..." She said, "We hit something, and I was pulled back into my seat." She broke down again, and started crying, not holding back her tears.
Matthew smiled, she thought it was her fault, that they crashed, and her parents died. "So it was your fault!" He said, and forced her to lay back down onto her back. "Oh you are gonna pay for what you've done!" He said, and got above her to fuck her again.
He started fucking her hard, he knew it wasn't really her fault, but he told her that, so he could get her emotional. Neither of the two girls in the pool heard the story Natalie had said, but heard Matthew saying it was her fault, and after asking about the crash.
Matthew fucked Natalie as hard as he could, and she had her hands on her mouth again. "You are now all of our slaves!" He said as he fucked her, "Because you killed our parents." He paused and focused on fucking her, then continued, "But, I am the one you obey no matter what they say, because you tried to kill me!" He said and hid his smile.
She thought it was reasonable punishment, because she now believed that she was trying to kill him, even though she wasn't, and she also believed that it was completely her fault for the crash, and that she did it on purpose, even though it wasn't. She mainly believed these things, because he kept telling her they were true, and eventually, she just believed it all.
Matthew finished in her, cleaned her off, and sent her to bed, but told her to just sleep in the skirt she was wearing. Olivia woke up shortly after Natalie left, and Matthew called them all over to him. He told them the story Natalie told him, but he modified it so it sounded like she did it on purpose, and intended for the crash.
"So now she is all of our slaves, but mine above you all, because she tried to kill me too." They went to bed shortly after, and they believed every word of what Matthew said, except Olivia was a little hesitant to believe it.
Olivia went to Natalie, she wasn't asleep yet, and she was on the couch. "Is it true, that you purposefully tried to kill our parents?" She asked. Natalie broke into tears again and nodded, Olivia was surprised that Matthew had told the truth, even though that wasn't really true.
Olivia got angry, and punched Natalie in the face, "Oh, you are gonna pay for this." They all went to bed, ready to release their anger on Natalie when they woke up.