Bill, Jesse, Lucas, and Andre all sat in the small seating area in Bill’s master bedroom. Normally, the love seat and two chairs were situated around a small fireplace. But today, they’d all been moved to provide them front row seats to the bed.
Lilly was sitting with her big sister in the center of the bed. She had one hand around Anna’s neck. The oldest girl was still recovering from Andre’s ass-fucking with a healthy collection of his cum inside her panties. It felt uncomfortable to move, so she tried to stay put as much as she could. She as close to her little sister as she could, doing her best to comfort herself. But their audience looked rather intimidating as they stared at both of them. And there was Andre with his camera, too…
“Now,” Robert stepped forward from the other side of the room. “It’s time for the real punishment to begin.” Anna took a deep breath, dreading what would come next. How could everything they’d gone through since they arrived at Bill’s house not be the “real punishment?” But their father was quick to explain.
“We all know what Anna did the other night, trying to rat Bill and I out her mother,” Robert took off his shirt and looked to Anna. “I’m sure you understand how disappointed I am in you. I thought you were my responsible eldest daughter who’s always looking out for your little sister, but I guess not…” Robert reached out and pulled Anna closer to him, motioning for her to help him take off his pants.
Anna started to fiddle with his belt as he went on, “As I helped your mother pack the next morning, I thought long and hard about what consequence would be appropriate. And I had quite a few great ideas, believe me.” Anna managed to undo his pants and they dropped to the ground. Then he handed her a bottle of lube he’d been holding.
“Lather me up,” he instructed, dropping his underwear, too. “Make sure you get it nice and good.” She obeyed without a word, squirting a healthy amount onto his cock and rubbing it all over with her other hand.
“But where was I?” Robert paused. “Ah yes, see, I had quite a few ideas but none of them seemed to fit. You’ve always been such a willing little slut, so I knew this one had to be something extra special.” Robert taunted her. Even though Anna felt as though she couldn’t be any less willing, her father’s words seemed true. She always agreed to do whatever he wanted, but only because he always made it seem as though Lilly was his back-up plan if she ever refused. Anna recognized the devious gleam in his eye. She hated that look.
“And then, just after you kids went to bed last night, it hit me,” Robert took a breath, finally coming to a conclusion. Though he didn’t finish his statement just yet. He pushed Anna’s hands away, satisfied that she had lubed him up thoroughly.
“I really think there’s only one thing that will actually get through to you,” Robert smirked, climbing onto the bed. He walked on his knees, closer where Lilly was sitting, holding herself up with both hands. He grabbed her ankles and pulled her toward him.
“Woah,” Lilly slid across the bed. No longer able to hold herself up, she fell backward while Robert opened up her legs in the same motion. She found herself on her back, legs nearly wrapped around her father.
“Dooon’t!” Anna whined, pulling at Robert’s arm when she realized his intention.
“Anna, relax she’ll be fine,” Robert gently ran the tip of his cock from Lilly’s pussy all the way down to her ass. The youngest girl had a hand in her mouth and looked down in uncertainty. He had rubbed her down there plenty of times, and cum all over her, too. Bur she understood he intended to go further this time.
“Now, Anna,” Robert grabbed her hand and placed it on his cock. “I can’t decide which virginity I want to take, so I thought you might like to choose instead.”
“Hey!” Lilly piped up, asserting that she aught to have some choice in the matter. But Robert ignored her.
“Come on, I bet you imagine me fucking one of your little sister’s holes all the time.” Robert lifted his hand to Anna’s wet hair. “Just stick my cock in the one you wanna see me fuck and you get to watch!” He kissed Anna on the forehead and she recoiled for a moment.
Barely composed, Anna sat there completely still with a lubed cock in her hand. She shut her eyes for a moment, wishing once again that dat that she could disappear. But she knew she had to make a choice. Lilly tried to speak one last time, but Robert told her to be quiet. It was Anna’s decision.
“What’ll it be?” He uttered.
Finally, Anna gave in and took a deep breath before slowly placing her father’s cock right at the entrance to Lilly’s ass. She knew it was bound to be easier. Lilly looked nervous and resumed biting the side of her hand, looking down anxiously.
Robert let out a satisfied sigh, feeling the tip of his cock resting at the entrance of Lilly’s rectum.
“Yeah, I figured you’d want me to fuck her little ass,” Robert teased again. Grabbing Lilly’s hips, he pushed forward just a bit. She didn’t react at first, but began to murmur when Robert pressed his cock in just a bit further.
Anna laid down next to her and put an arm around her little sister. Lilly’s body began to twitch when Robert managed more of his cock inside her, causing Anna to tighten her embrace.
“So fucking tight!” He complemented, pushing himself as far as he dared into the small girl. Lilly whined. Robert relaxed for a moment before pulling his cock back and pushing it forward again slowly. He was going easy on her, but still managed to elicit a few repeated cries from her.
“Awe yeah,” he moaned. “That’s my five year old little fucking whore.” Lilly grabbed onto Anna tightly as he continued. With that, he offered his hardest thrust yet, causing Lilly to cry out and shake. This time a tear escaped and Anna reached up to wipe it away.
“You know, if you really want to make Lilly feel better, eat her cunt or something!” Robert teased Anna. He followed up his suggestion with a few more thrusts. Lilly writhed and the sudden increase in pressure and whined once again.
Anna thought briefly before giving Lilly a peck on the cheek. She couldn’t deny that her father’s suggestion seemed like a good one and so, she broke their embrace and crawled down to her pussy. All the while, annoyed with the sticky mess of cum in her panties as she moved.
Getting into position, She plopped down on her stomach and put her head right in Lilly’s snatch. Then she gave it a gentle lick. Her father’s stomach rubbed against her face with each thrust. But she did her best not to let it bother her and put her tongue to work.
As things progressed, Lilly began to grow accustomed to her father’s movements, though her whines continued. But Anna’s handiwork was steadily making a bigger impact as she continued. Their father’s torso pushed against Anna’s face while her tongue went on dancing around Lilly’s clit.
Suddenly, a sound of tearing fabric filled the room and it took a moment for Anna to realize someone was ripping off her panties. The sound of cheers and claps followed from the audience on the other side of the room.
As she continued to eat out her younger sister, she felt a cock exploring her backside before suddenly burrowing itself in her pussy from behind. Whoever it was, had grabbed her hips and began driving himself into her. It was difficult to keep her tongue working on Lilly as it continued, but she managed.
With her eyes half open, Lilly looked up at Bill as he drove himself in and out of her big sister. With Anna eating her out, the pressure of their father’s cock in her ass didn’t seem quite so bad anymore. It had at least made it all more bearable.
Lilly yelped a few more times, twitching in discomfort when Robert suddenly picked up the pace. But moments later, the pressure in her ass started to relax. He had shot his first bullet of cum into her ass and pulled out, aiming straight at Lilly’s cunt.
Anna felt cum land on her tongue and tasted it immediately. It was unpleasant, but she continued to swirl her tongue around her sister’s privates. Another shot of cum hit her nose while more landed on Lilly’s pussy and dripped onto the bed.
Bill was continuing to thrust in and out of Anna from behind while Robert finished cumming on his girls, determined to make Anna’s job taste as much like his cum as he could. She gagged, but didn’t let up. His final spurts landed on her cheek and she felt them drip down.
As for Lilly, Anna’s tongue was having quite the effect without her father’s cock distracting her. She began to grasp and pull against the bed sheets and shortly began to coo as her orgasm hit her. Anna felt the girl’s legs twitch underneath her, all the while continuing to swirl her father’s cum around Lilly’s snatch with her tongue.
“What a big girl!” Robert complemented Lilly once her orgasm had subsided. She didn’t respond as he sat on the side of the bed and lifted her to him.
Meanwhile, Bill began to thrust into Anna with greater force. Without Lilly’s pussy in her face, she was finally able to look back to see that it was Bill who had been ramming her with his cock. With a few more impatient movements, he moaned and panted aloud as he filled Anna’s pussy with his jizz, pushing himself into her as far as he could.
When Bill was finished, he pulled away and left a stream of his cum leaking out from Anna’s nine year old cunt. Lilly was by Robert, feeling a little bewildered by the whole thing. Lilly wiped some hair out of her face and put a hand on Anna’s head. Her older sister’s backside was no longer in the air and she took a moment to relax on the bed.
“Well, I think it’s time for you to take a bath,” Robert spoke to Lilly. “Then we can go home.”
“Okay,” Lilly answered quietly as she was scooped up. Jesse had walked over and was waiting to receive her. Lilly didn’t speak as she was handed off to the other man, though she remembered that he was the one that got to keep her pink shirt…
Anna pushed herself up and watched Jesse take her sister to the master bathroom just before a pair of hand grabbed her, too. She looked up to see Bill’s nephew, Lucas lifting her off the bed.
“Go pop that cherry, kid!” Bill gave him a slap on the back, obviously referring to Lucas’ cherry and not Anna’s. She, too kept quiet as he carried her to Bill’s guest bathroom and got the tub going. Lucas had slipped his boxer briefs back on, but pulled them down as the bath began to fill up.
“You and your sister are really hot,” Lucas admitted. Anna was sitting on the toilet seat, bare bottom against the cool porcelain and slouched as they waited.
“Wouldn’t you rather lose your virginity to someone older with—boobies?” Anna asked.
“No way,” Lucas turned to look at her and gently pushed her against the back of the toilet. “Boobs just get in the way. Your flat chest is so much prettier.” He ran a hand over her nipples and down to her stomach.
“You don’t have any hair down there either,” he reached down and felt the smoothness of Anna’s twat. “Woman’s pussies are so messy, but yours is perfect.” He leaned in and kissed Anna, putting his legs on either side of her and rubbing his cock on her. She felt his precum on her stomach as she kissed him back.
Lucas had nearly forgotten about the bath, but managed to break their kiss just in time to turn off the water. With their bath ready, Lucas helped Anna into the tub and climbed in after. She gladly washed herself up, cleaning up everywhere she thought cum might be. Her hair was already clean, of course, thanks to Andre’s efforts at the sink. But she dipped her head down anyway and got her hair wet again.
Lucas settled in himself and wasted little time putting his hands back on Anna’s body, “Such a hot little slut!” He began touching her all over once more and then, he climbed on top of her.
He moaned, feeling himself rub against Anna’s perfect, hairless body. Lucas could hardly believe what was about to happen. It took him a moment to adjust, but he managed to figure out how to line up his cock with Anna’s pussy and pushed into her eagerly.
“Oh fuck,” he moaned, driving his cock up her tight snatch. “It fees so nice. So fucking….” He paused and Anna just sat in the water beneath him, feeling his chest move with each breath. The teen steadily began to move, splashing water all around them as he fucked her.
“Tell me you love my big cock!” Lucas whispered in her ear.
“I love your big cock,” Anna repeated, despite finding it quite a bit smaller than the man-cocks she’d been acquainted with.
“I love your fucking cunt!” Lucas pulled her head back and began to kiss Anna passionately as he drove himself into her. She found herself returning the kiss and moments later, wrapped her legs around him. The girl was suddenly holding onto him tightly as she felt his thrusts continue.
Anna was surprised when she realized Lucas’ movements were indeed having an affect on her. She began to moan and grasped his shoulder. He kept the pace, making waves in the tub that began splashing out on the bathroom floor with more force. Their moans echoed off the hard surfaces of the room.
When Anna’s orgasm began to hit her, she gripped him tighter. His thrusts went on as the wave came over her and own orgasm quickly followed. He let out a much louder sound that must have echoed down the hall, pumping his first pussy full with his seed.
“That was fun,” Lucas noted when it was over. The water was still making waves in the bath as it calmed down.
“It was,” Anna had to admit. Lucas stretched out and nestled in next to her. They sat in the tub together for a time until there was a knock on the bathroom door.
“You kid’s done in there?” Bill asked through the door. “Robert is about to leave.”
“We’re coming!” Lucas stood up, grabbing a towel off the rack. There was a second which he gave to Anna. Together, they dried themselves.
Anna wrapped her towel around her torso just as Lucas opened the bathroom door. She walked out first, heading back to the master bedroom where everyone else was still congregating.
When she stepped back in, she felt everyone’s eyes follow her.
“Did you have fun?” Bill asked Lucas who was right behind her.
“Yes,” Anna answered, blushing when she heard Lucas start to speak and realized Bill hadn’t been asking her.
“It was fucking awesome!” Lucas replied, grabbing Anna by the shoulder.
Her father and Andre were both sitting with Bill. It had been a rough afternoon, but at least she’d had a little fun. And now, her father was dressed again and it seemed that it was nearly over.
Looking back, Anna spotted Lilly and Jesse making their way out of the master bathroom to join the rest of them.
“Well, I officially have the cleanest cock in the world!” Jesse announced proudly, complementing the handjob the five year old had given him as he led her back to the room. She had apparently already dried off and ditched her towel. He paraded the kid back over to where the men were sitting.
“Hey, why don’t you go find your overalls and bring them here and I’ll help you fasten them,” Robert said to Lilly.
“Okay,” the naked girl ran past Anna and Lucas, heading back to the family room.
Anna remembered her dress and gave her father an annoyed glance, “What am I supposed to wear? My dress is ripped!”
“Oh, don’t worry about that right now,” Robert answered. Lilly came back into the room, barreling forward with her unlatched overalls pulled up. She wore nothing underneath, since all her other garments had been forfeited.
“Why? I have to wear clothes, too!” Anna asked with a fair bit of attitude. Robert gladly helped Lilly with her overalls before answering.
“Actually, you don’t need clothes because I’m leaving you here for the night!” Robert sounded proud of himself. He would have honestly loved to stay, but the thought of how utterly and completely helpless Anna would be at the mercy of all the men if he just abandoned her was too good to pass up.
Ann felt a sudden chill in the air, “Yy—you can’t leave me here!” She begged, loosening the grip on her towel, causing it to expose her nipples.
“This is not a debate, young lady!” Robert said calmly and stood up, walking closer. “These men all deserve a good time and I know you want to give it to them.”
“But I don’t want to!” Anna cried, feeling her father pull her towel away. “Pleeeeaaase!” Anna dropped to her knees.
“Alright, you don’t have to stay if you really don’t want to,” Robert put a hand in Anna’s wet hair. “We can leave Lilly here instead. Just say the word and I’ll take you home right now. I’m just everyone here would love a crack at her last virgin hole.” Robert gave Anna a naughty smile while Lilly fluttered a little at his side upon hearing the suggestion.
“No, it’s okay,” Anna answered, almost shaking as she said it. “I want to stay.” She slouched on the floor, accepting her fate.
“I knew you’d want to,” Robert stood up. “Lilly, say goodbye to your sister and we’ll get outta here.” For perhaps the first time, Lilly clearly understood what was at stake. She didn’t like the idea of leaving Anna behind, but…
“Thank you, Anna,” Lilly reached out and hugged her big sister. It was the first time the youngest girl realized how much Anna actually did for her.
“See you tomorrow,” Anna hugged her back, trying not to sound too dispirited. At that, Robert led his youngest out of the room, leaving Anna on her knees at the mercy if the four men in front if her.