2T4U/Jack/Morning/Fiona's/Keep talking to her a little longer to convince her she wants it
“Well, I'm not going to rape you,” you tell her. “I only have sex with girls who want it.”
“Hmmph” she grunts again. You smile to yourself a bit and decide to go lay down across the foot of her bed with your hips a good way on to the corner.
“You know what though?” You add, “I think you want it. I'm not going to do anything until you say you do though.”
“What?” She responds, looking over at you for a moment and then quickly averting her gaze. “Umm...”
“See there?” You ask her, “You didn't deny it. I can usually tell these things.”
“I...” she trails off with a far-off distracted look in her eyes.
“Think about this,” you add on. “Getting raped by the boy she stupidly leaves you with and having consensual sex with the boy she stupidly leaves you with are almost as bad as each other so far as she is concerned. It would be another way to get one on her.”
“Hmmm... I... I've... never done it before.” She confesses with a down-turned nervous and worried look at the mattress.
That's close enough, get up and fuck her.
- Just do it. Un-zip, grab her, and fuck her
- Talk to her and keep convincing her she wants it while actually fucking her
- Assure her you'll teach her while you move in and do it
Not quite enough to count as permission, keep working on her