I finished my lunch as slowly as possible, taking tiny bites and chewing slow because I knew I would have to do stuff with all the men when I was done. Hannah was already busy with two cocks. I could see her from the kitchen holding both of them and sucking them back and forth when they told her to switch.
I wasn’t sitting on mommy’s lap anymore because she went to answer the door. It was nice to be alone, but I could hear her greeting another man.
Over the kitchen counter, I spotted two new men in the family room that must have come while Hannah and I were upstairs. And there was the other new man in the living room. So that meant there were six. And if you count my brothers, that made eight cocks that Hannah and I would have to make feel good.
Most of the men were in the family room drinking beer. Except I think my brothers probably had root beer. Seeing how many men were there reminded me of the dinner party where I lost my virginity. It seemed weird that I liked Jim now when he was the one that ripped off my dress and raped me on the kitchen table. I really hated him then. I wondered if these men would pass Hannah and me around like I had been that night.
“Savoring that sandwich are we?” I looked up and saw Hannah’s daddy walk into the kitchen from the family room. “Don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone eat so slow before.” He wasn’t naked like earlier, but he was still only wearing underwear.
“I’m hungry,” I realized that was a stupid thing to say, but it was the only thing I could think of.
“I bet you just need some dessert,” he said. He walked to the kitchen island and grabbed a package of Oreos that were sitting there next to some of the leftover chips.
“You like Oreos, Naomi?” I nodded slowly. “Me, too.” He sat down next to me and took one out of the package.
“What’s your favorite part?” He asked me. I suddenly felt cold and folded my arms.
“The middle,” I answered, carefully.
“Yes, that’s my favorite, too,” he agreed. “Never cared for the rest when I was your age.” He opened up the cookie in his hand and held it up in front of me.
“Well, go on,” he moved it in between his fingers. I didn’t trust him, especially after what he’d done to me earlier. But I leaned forward slowly and licked the cream.
“Good?” He asked. I nodded. He ate the black part before grabbing another for me to lick. The third time, he licked off some of the filling first and then let me lick off the rest. I didn’t know why he was doing it, but it tasted good, so I didn’t complain.
A few cookies later, he licked off all the cream and stuck his tongue out. The cream sat there on his tongue and I knew what he wanted. I got out of my chair to get closer. Then I leaned in so I could suck his tongue. I put my mouth right over it and tasted the beer he’d been drinking. But then I tasted the Oreo cream after that which tasted a lot better.
He had me lick one off next and share it with him the same way. I helt it out on my tongue and waited for him to kiss me. Even though I didn’t really like Hannah’s Dad, it was actually kind of fun. It would have been a lot more fun if I was doing it with Jim instead. It also would have been more fun if his breath didn’t taste like beer!
After a few cookies, we had stopped eating the black part at all. We would just lick off the cream and leave the rest on the table. I grabbed a few more cookies and broke one apart.
“Why don’t we go see if Hannah wants some Oreo’s, too?” He suggested. I was surprised her dad was being so nice. It felt weird, but I figured Hannah would like to eat some Oreo’s, too.
“Okay,” I licked the Oreo I had in my hand and at it like normal. Then I grabbed the whole package of cookies and turned toward the living room. That’s when I saw Hannah was still sitting on the sofa sucking one of the new guy’s cocks. My dad was there, too, but it looked like he had just cum because he was soft. When I got closer, I could see Hannah had some goo on the side of her face. But It looked like my daddy had wanted to get as much as he could into her hair, because there was a lot more running down it.
“Hey, Hannah, we thought you might like to have a break for some Oreo cookies,” Hannah’s dad walked into the room behind me. Hannah pulled away from the man’s cock, but still held it with one hand when she saw me.
“Oh, thanks!” She let go of the cock and reached out for the box of Oreos when I offered her some, but her dad stopped me.
“No, not like that!” Hannah’s dad motion. “Do it like were were doing”
“Oh…” I slouched and set the cookies down on the coffee table. “Okay.” I grabbed one and Hannah watched me open it and lick the cream. When I stuck my tongue out, she was confused for a second, but understood when her dad pushed her forward.
I felt Hannah’s lips surround my tongue and I kissed her so we could share the cream. Then she licked a cookie and we did it again. That time, I accidentally touched a bunch of Hannah’s hair and got some goo on my hand. I wiped it off on my knee and then we shared another cookie.
The guys started coming back into the room after that and I guess they liked our show because they kept having us eat more cookies. Our dads both sat on the sofa with us and the three other guys sat on the other sofa. I was too busy making out with Hannah to know where my brothers were, but I eventually saw them grab chairs from the dining room. Then both of our moms sat nearby, too.
I didn’t like that there were so many people watching us. But it was fun eating so many sweets. Normally I wouldn’t have been allowed to eat so much.
“Okay girls, last one!” My dad pulled the cookie out of the box. I didn’t know how many we had eaten, but there was a big pile of the black cookies parts that we’d ignored and the box was completely empty.
“I guess we should have bought some more,” Hannah’s dad commented.
“Nah, I think I have an idea,” I saw the guy Hannah had been sucking earlier stand up from where we was on the sofa and walk over to the coffee table. But I didn’t see what he was doing because I took the cookie from my dad and then Hannah and I started to make out again. I heard a few of the guys taking quietly and noises from the one who’d stood up, but didn’t pay any attention until Hannah and I had finished kissing.
I thought we’d had the last cookie, but I was surprised to see another one in the man’s hand. But then I realized it was covered with a different kind of cream filling. I wished we’d kept eating the black parts when I realized what it was.
“Ew!” Hannah said. “That’s gross!”
“Nonsense,” her dad said from behind me on the sofa. “You girls love the cream filling, and Tanner just wants to be friendly, so he’s made you some more!”
Then the guy stuck the cookie in Hannah’s face and she stuck her tongue out to lick it. I could tell she really didn’t want to, though. She moved slow an kind of gagged when she tasted it. Just like the real Oreo filling, though, she held it out on her tongue and I knew that I was supposed to kiss her again.
I felt my dad’s hand push me forward and our tongues touched. Making out with man-goo was a lot less fun than Oreo filling. But all the men seemed to like us eating that more because they started laughing and cheering.
And when we were finished with that one, there was another black cookie with sperm on it in my face this time. It was my turn to lick it off and then Hannah and I made out again. Tanner had made four cookies for us with his jizz. Hannah and I were both glad that nobody else had made more. But they had other ideas…
“Okay, kids,” Hannah’s dad leaned over. “Get over here, it’s time you girls get to be the cream filling.
“Daddy, you’re silly,” Hannah got off the sofa and walked over to her dad. “We can’t be cream filling!” My dad grabbed me and pulled me into his lap.
“Sure you can, you’ll see,” I saw him grab Hannah and then he pointed toward me. “Naomi will show you how it’s done.” I was confused. I didn’t know how to “be” cream filling. But my dad lifted me up and I felt his cock pushing into my ass. I gasped when he pulled me down, then I felt myself open up even more and I fell further into his lap. A few seconds later, he was up inside me so far I could feel the hairs around my daddy’s cock were tickling my bottom.
“Okay, who’s first?” My dad asked. I didn’t know what he meant, but I saw one of the new guys stand up from the other sofa. He was still dressed, but started undoing his belt while he stepped up to me. That’s when I realized what was about to happen—and what Hannah's daddy had meant.
“Nooo,” I whined. Right when I said it, Daddy grabbed my ankles and put my feet up on his knees. The man’s pants fell down and I watched him pull off his underwear next.
“Please, I don’t want to!” I whined. I had only been stuck in between two men like that once when I was in Florida and I’d hated it.
“How many men had you been with now?” My daddy whispered in my ear. “17 isn’t it?” I didn’t answer.
“Well here comes number 18, sweetie,” my dad added. “I’m so proud of my little whore!” Then the man stepped up and I whined again when his cock touched my kitty.
“Relax, it’s not even inside you yet,” Daddy said and rubbed my chest. I still tried to wriggle around when the guy rubbed a little of his precum stuff on my kitty. I was still stuck all the way on my dad’s cock, though.
“Daddy, I don’t want to do that,” I heard Hannah say.
“Shhh, just watch,” as soon as he said, I felt the other man’s cock pushing into me. I winced and arched my back. I whined
“Oh fuck!” The man in my kitty moaned. “She’s so tight!” I complained and wriggled as I felt him pushing in and slipping further inside. I looked down and saw more of his cock disappearing while I felt both cocks expanding my holes. Then it got worse when he started pushing in and out.
I heard him moaning a lot. His chest rubbed against my face and he cried out each time he thrusted. My dad didn't move as much since I was sitting on him, but a few times he pushed up right then the other guy moved back into me and it was the worst!
I'm pretty sure I cried the whole time and just wanted it to be over. Being filled up from both sides was too much. But when I said anything, they didn't listen and there was nothing I could do but just let them fuck me.
The man grabbed at my hair and touched me all over. He even leaned down to kiss me, but I don’t think I did a good job kissing him back. After fucking my kitty and touching me for a while, he finally shot his goo inside me.
He moaned a lot before he finished and I was glad when he pulled out. A lot of cum dripped out of me when he did. My daddy’s cock was still in my butt, but I felt like I could relax a little.
I saw another guy walking up to me, though. I whimpered because I knew he wanted to fuck me, too. He was already naked and I remembered he was the one who had made Hannah and me eat his cum off the Oreos.
"It's okay, sweetie," Daddy kissed my cheek after I whined again. "You're a strong little girl." I knew I was, but I didn't feel very strong when he walked up in between my legs.
"Watching you get double penetrated got me hard again so fast," Tanner admitted and then I felt him push the tip of his cock into me. I felt my dad start to moving more this time, too. I tried to wriggle around again, but it didn't do any good. I looked over at Hannah again and she looked really scared, but she was still just sitting on her Daddy's lap.
I decided to just close my eyes and lean my head back against my dad’s chest. I tried to imagine I was with Jim at his beach house and that he was one of the cocks inside me. That made me feel a little better, so I kept my eyes closed while they finished.
After I felt Tanner pull out of my kitty, I felt some goo splash against my chest. I was glad I had my eyes closed, too because a lot more land splattered on my fave. When I finally opened my eyes and looked down, I saw some of it it dripping down to my stomach and then in between my legs.
I felt gross, but my dad grabbed my waist before I could wipe any of it off and started bouncing me really fast on his lapx Suddenly, I worried that it was someone else's turn to fuck me. But when I looked up, nobody was in front of me this time. My dad moaned and I felt his cock shooting. Then my dad's cock slipped out of me, too. That's when I heard Hannah.
"Mommy, tell them I don't want to," I looked up and saw Hannah leaning over the arm of the sofa and trying to wrestle with her dad.
"Come on now, you want to be a good girl for all these men, don't you?" Hannah's mom said. "Men are a lot nicer to good girls. Here, we’ll have one of the kids get you warmed up, though. That way you’ll feel more comfortable." Hannah’s mom grabbed Andy’s hand and led him over to her.
By then, Hannah’s dad had already put his cock up her ass and she was wriggling in his lap. Hannah’s mom helped Andy take his pants off and then I watched her grab his cock and rub it against Hannah’s kitty. She made a sound and kept wriggling around. But her mom helped Andy get his cock in place and I saw his cock start to disappear inside my friend.
He got into it and pushed himself in all the way while she whined. Hannah tried to push him away, but he grabbed her hands and held them out while he fucked her. Andy went faster and I saw Hannah close her eyes like I did.
I didn’t see much after that because one of the other men I didn’t know walked over and picked me up out of my dad’s lap.
“Hey, sweetheart,” he had taken his shirt off and I felt the goo in my kitty squish between us. He didn’t seem to mind, bit he did wipe off my face with a t-shirt he had found on the floor. The shirt smelled kid of funny, though and when he finished wiping me up, I realize that it wasn’t a shirt at all. It was the pair of pants that Hannah had peed in when she’d gotten here. At least they were dry by then.
He tossed the pants back on the ground and I barely remember what happened after that. He sat down put his cock inside me and then when he came, I had to suck off the man sitting next to us. Eventually, I was just laying on the sofa and I saw Sean jerking off over me while the Tanner guy lifted my legs up and stuck his cock up my bottom. I felt a hand turn my head and looked up to see Hannah’s daddy.
For a second, I was able to see Hannah on the other sofa. Her naked body was bent her over the arm rest and one of the other guys had his hands on her head and was pushing himself in and out of her mouth. My daddy was sitting on his knees behind with his cock inside her. Hannah’s pretty long hair was just dangling there back and forth. Then my dad pulled his cock out and I saw him shooting his goo over her back.
Her dad blocked my view when he put his cock in my face, though, so I couldn't see her anymore. I could only see his stomach because pushed his cock into my mouth hard and made me gag. He grabbed my head and I tensed up because I knew he was probably going to push in again harder. That’s when I heard Tanner talking to my brother.
“Hey bro, get your dick up her cunt and we’ll have her air tight,” I had never heard the phrase before, but I heard my brother agree and felt him climbing on top of me.
My brother pushed my legs around and leaned on me. At the same time, Hannah’s dad kept pushing his cock deep into my mouth and Tanner was still thrusting into my backside. Then Sean found my kitty hole and I heard him moan when his cock entered me.
Suddenly, I felt really full again like earlier. But this time I had a cock in my mouth, too.
“That’s it, take it in all three holes you little whore!” Hannah’s dad said. I felt scared and just wanted it over. But I think my brother was going really slow on purpose and kept rubbing my arm so I would feel better. Sean wad always nice like that.
I was glad when Hannah’s Daddy started to cum, even though he was doing it right in my mouth. But I knew that meant he was finished with me for now. He still made me gag a few more times and his cum tasted gross, but he eventually pulled out of my mouth. I wasn’t able to swallow much, so his goo got all over my cheeks and ran down my neck. He wiped the tip of his cock in my hair and walked to the kitchen to get more beer.
I was worried someone else was going to make me suck them since he was dine. But I saw one man with his cock in Hannah’s mouth and a few other men jerking off over her while she was laying on the couch.
I felt more relief when Tanner suddenly pulled out of my butt. I felt his goo leaking out of me when he did.
“Ew, you got jizz on my balls!” Sean complained.
“Shut the fuck up, kid,” Tanner dad told him. I couldn’t help but laugh, a little.
“I’m so glad you’re my little sister,” Sean kissed my forehead and then went faster. I wrapped my legs around him while he moaned and finished inside me.
I got a little break after Sean was done, but I know I sucked a few more cocks after that. And at least one guy jerked off on me. But I was so tired by then that I was half asleep. I remember hearing my mom and dad thank a few people for coming, so I knew some of the guys were leaving.
“Here, let’s let the girls rest,” I heard Hannah’s dad say. Then I felt someone against me on the sofa. When I felt her long hair on my arm, I realized it was Hannah. I opened my eyes for a second and we hugged each other.
I saw goo stuck in her hair and on her face. I felt a lot squish between us, too. But I was too tired to care and Hannah had already closed her eyes. Neither of us said anything and we both fell asleep on the sofa together.