Offline/Speak up, Hannah's turn is over
Nodding your head to grab Jet's attention, you gesture at the show before you. He smiles and nods back, holding his cock out to the side and surreptitiously rubbing it with his thumb. That response wasn't what you were going for.
"Is time up? I think Hannah is done, right?"
"Yeah, okay... time, time," Jet reluctantly announces.
"Wait!" shouts Hannah. Her fingers come flying out from their occupied holes and Hannah drops down beside Nicole. She pointedly presses two fingertips to Nicole's mouth then says, a touch short of breath, "I mean, I guess you don't have to now... but if you want to... it'd be super hot..."
Being forced to contemplate such an offer when her mind is already swimming in sex seems to be a pretty effective way to push Nicole's boundaries. Your cousin calmly, steadily, draws Hannah's digits into her mouth, her head craning to the side and lifting off of the sleeping bag to help inch her lips down each of Hannah's knuckles. She pulls all the way off at the same deliberate pace, smacks her lips together, then does it all again one more time, all while Hannah stares into her eyes. Hannah isn't pushing her fingers into Nicole's mouth, Hannah is making your cousin do all the work. She wants her to want it. It occurs to you that Nicole is just mimicking what she saw Hannah do to your fingers, but it's still stupid hot. Does Nicole even realize the fingers she's sucking were the ones inside Hannah?
While Nicole is still finishing her second slow suck, Hannah turns to you. "I'm sorry Jay. Nicky's my new favorite cousin."
"Yeah... well... she's... my favorite too... so..." You're way too flustered by all this to offer a comeback. Frankly, cum is about the only thing you could offer right now. You just lower Nicole's leg and sit back, trying to contain your jealousy.
"Okay, well that was ah-mazing," states Hannah, cockily rating herself. She takes a moment to straighten her panties before crawling to her seat, announcing, "It's your turn again, Naughty Nicky!"
Jet scrunches up his face in confusion, dick still in hand. "Or we could just, y'know... fuck already."
"Ew! What are you talking about!" Hannah really sells her mock offense at her boyfriend's suggestion. "We're playing a game Jet! This is all just harmless fun! Right Nicky?"
"Uh... yeah... ew!" copies Nicole, clearly confused, bewildered even, still laying naked on the floor. "It's not like... that was serious. It was just, y'know... a joke."
"See? Really Jet..." she scolds once more before turning back to Nicole. "You're just the best at this game Nicky! Ready for your turn?"
Nicole is hardly thinking clearly. At best her mind is clouded. She's only just bringing her legs together and lifting herself off her back. But she offers up the one thing clearly on her mind. "Never... have I ever... had sex."
Hannah grins and glances around the room. "Really? That's your whole question? Nothing to add? Like an exception or something?"
"Y-yeah. No," Nicole replies, afraid she misspoke somehow.
"Okaaay. Buuuut... you and me? We were definitely just doing the lesbians." Hannah playfully flicks her tongue on that L. "So... I guess you're just asking us for a dare then! Happy to do it, by the way, but I gotta say this feels like cheating!"
Nicole looks down at her rosy pussy lips and then across to Hannah. "Wha...?"
"Lesbian sex is still sex. Girls don't go borrow a penis to do it with each other. Yeah, dildos, I know," Hannah adds, cutting off her boyfriend. He smiles and tilts his head back, bemused, before Hannah continues "So I dunno how you thought girls did it, but what we just did totally counts!"
Nicole argues briefly with stammered words then gives up as she comes to the realization that she may have 'officially' lost her virginity to another girl.
"Okay, okay, I'll tell you what. If I really wasn't good enough for you then I'll give you a dare you must clearly want. Your dare can be... to put your pussy on a real live penis... Jay's... for one minute."
"I have to what?"
"Sure!" you eagerly agree.
"What's wrong with that? Since you're worried about being a lesbian, you should find out what a penis feels like."
Nicole looks very conflicted, though she does smirk when she meets your dumb joyful gaze. "But... you mean... you don't want us to have sex?"
That's a weird question. Does she want to do that?
"No! Of course not!" insists Hannah. She again stresses, "We're just having fun silly! Just rub up on him, tease him, make him wish you would. Do your grindy twerky thing, whatever you want, but you have to go nonstop, for a full minute. Really, it's a pretty easy dare," she assures yet again.
Nicole takes a long look at the boner in your lap before convincing herself to do this. She shuffles over on her knees then looks to you to perhaps offer some guidance. You just lean back, placing your hands on the floor behind you and your legs in front of you, happy as can be.
"Stop smiling," demands Nicole.
You actually can't. "Why?"
"Because! You're making me smile! And it's weird."
You swear Hannah softly "aww"s from the corner. You do the best you can to hide your nervous joy as Nicole straddles your lap. She has no idea how to actually go about this so she just widens her legs to lower her crotch closer to you. As they get wider she places her hands on your lowered shoulders to help support herself.
She looks amazing right now. Everything about her. The nerdy glasses, black choker, slightly disheveled ponytail, slender stretched limbs, and her utterly flawless naked body, it's all completely perfect. She may not have the more noticeable curves that Hannah does, and without pubes she looks a little closer to how you'd imagine your sister, but you still wouldn't change a thing. And then she makes contact.
Since you've leaned back a bit your junk is now pointing straight up in the air, so as Nicole sits she hits the very tip of your cock. She has to wiggle and roll her hips to get her underside to push you down. Using her hand would be a lot easier, but she's probably just following the dare to the letter. And maybe is a little scared about touching her first penis. She sure looks nervous. But with a careful tilt of her hips she successfully deflects the head of your cock off of her pussy and underneath her, your head nestling into the bottom of her ass, her pussy mound resting atop your shaft.
She just wiggles a little at first, still unsure. "You're counting right?" she asks over her shoulder.
"Of course! Don't worry about it. Just have fun!"
With that encouragement, Nicole slides her body back, then forward. She's actually sliding along your thighs which she is fully sitting on making her movements slow and jerky. Even she knows it's weird though and after a few uncomfortable passes she lifts her butt and thighs off of you just enough to let her glide above you, only making contact with your dick as it pulls up against her. That change lets her roll her pelvis and helps her narrow vulva part. As soon as your shaft separates her lips you can feel a slick warmth coat your skin. She's really wet, although you'd expect her to be after her intimate foray with Hannah.
"You're still smiling..."
"Sorry."
Nicole lifts a little higher and leans forward, placing her forehead on your shoulder to look down under her so she can watch what she's doing. It feels like a strange angle but neither of you have done this before. She's trying to grind against the top of your head now, sandwiching it between her lips and dipping down to bring her clit into the fray where she can. It's pretty amazing already, but you really want to adjust.
"Sorry, can I just..." you apologize, placing your hand on Nicole's hip. She straightens up quite sharply.
"Oh. Yeah, sure."
Reaching down under her, you slide down your dick and pull your foreskin all the way back to reveal your tip glistening with precum. If she's going to grind you, you want her to touch your glans bare. You want to feel her folds slide past your ridge.
"Okay. Go ahead."
Nicole lowers herself expecting to return to where she was and lands straight down onto your cock. In an instant your tip pops between her lips and up inside her slick pussy. You can feel her entrance squeeze you right away, gripping the unexpected intruder with excitement. Weirdly you've stopped smiling. You're just as surprised as Nicole whose mouth drops open in shock. She stares straight into your eyes as she registers what just happened. You're both really tense in this moment. Anything could happen. But she pulls off of you and you spring forward just as you flex your dick.
"Sorry! Sorry!" she repeats.
"No, it's okay. It was... fine."
Nicole hovers over you for a moment, losing her nerve. It's Nicole's dare so you're hesitant to do anything.
"You're not done yet!" warns Hannah. "We'll reset if we have to."