PIP/Shunned/Hannah in the loop
I noticed Hannah was acting really nervous and looking down a lot. She seemed to be struggling against me, like she was trying to get out. "Umm..." She made a noise like she urgently wanted to ask something and looked me straight in the eye, but then she seemed to have a thought that told her not to say whatever she was about to. I could probably guess what it was though.
"Yeah, we just finished having sex. I got my semen inside you." I told her. After I said this, she stopped struggling and then she started to whimper and her eyes started misting up.
"Mmm... what... what would I do if I ever got pregnant though? Mom said..." She was still trying not to seem like she was acknowledging me, but that was enough of a direct response to what I just told her that there was absolutely no doubt she could hear and understand what I was saying. Well, moment of truth then. Time to tell her about my plan."
"It's fine." I told her. "I'll make sure mom doesn't get you into too much trouble. I'm going to make it so every single girl in your class is pregnant, that way she can't get mad at you. It'll just be a strange epidemic of pregnancies in your school, and you are just one of them. Nobody will be able to blame you. And, that way we can have fun having sex like this more."
She went silent again. She seemed like she was stunned. "I... I really wonder what having a real boy's penis inside me would feel like." She oddly says as though none of what you just did even happened. "I heard someone say it feels like explosions for a girl when it's really good, I wonder if that can't happen because it's a dream." That's when I realized, did she think she was dreaming right now? Well, I reasoned that would make her a little more cooperative and less frightened at least. More immediately important though was the other part she said. Was she complaining about how she didn't get to cum?
"Alright, we can keep going until you have your own orgasm." I told her and started rocking my hips again, but this time I brought my hands up to play with her now completely exposed breasts under her night gown. Hannah gasped while I kneaded her soft budding mounds and my penis was making disgusting wet farting noises as it stirred around inside her and agitated the cum I had already filled her with. Because I had just emptied my balls out inside her a moment ago, I was at no threat of cumming again any time soon. So, I was able to just dedicate myself to giving her pleasure. Eventually, her moans became less and less restrained and increased in volume. Then, finally, I was rewarded for my efforts with her crying out in ecstasy and, in a strange way, the feeling that gave me was even better than releasing the contents of my balls into her pussy.
I felt like I was just glowing after doing all of that, but something about it felt wrong. I knew I had just cum a little bit ago, but even so, it somehow felt weird to stop with my penis still stiff and having not punctuated the whole experience with another ejaculation specifically at the end. I wanted to shoot more semen before I stopped, even if she was already full of the stuff.