The Babysitter and the Sisterly Trio/ChapterIII/Riley
I answer the door, and Riley is standing there holding a bowl of ice cream. "Is Evy okay?" she asks. "I've got her favorite ice cream. It always cheers her up."
I stand aside and let her in. She looks around the living room, and I realize she's looking for Evy. "Um, Evy's upstairs. I fixed her doll, and was drawing her a bath."
She looks startled. "You fixed her doll? How?"
"I sewed the arm back on."
"And she let you do that? She won't even let me hold her dolls, and I'm the one who has to take care of her a lot of the time."
She ponders that for a moment, then exclaims "Wait! Evy really hates the water. Usually mom or dad have to give her a bath, or I take one with her. Do you need any help?"
Oh my god! Is she offering to take a bath with Evy? I can't be this lucky, can I? Two naked little girls in my bathroom together!?
I try to calm my racing heart. "Uh, yeah. If you could help that'd be great. Its up this way."
I show Riley to my room. Evy hasn't moved since I left, and is still hugging the massive teddy bear I set out for her.
"Evy, Riley's here to see you."
She sits up, and notices the bowl Riley is carrying. "Is that ice cream for me...?" she asks.
"Yep, I went to go get it for you." Riley replies. Evy smiles and hugs Riley. "Thanks, Riley! You're the best!~" Riley hands Evy the bowl, and she eagerly starts to devour the ice cream.
"Let me check the water temperature, I know just how she likes it." says Riley. I let her past and she fiddles with the dials for a bit, feeling the water until it's just right.
"Okay, Evy. I've got the water how you like it."
Evy sets the bowl down (it was polished clean), and stands up.
"Help me please, Rei?" She holds out her arms and I realize she wants me to undress her.
I lift up her dress and pull it up over her head, then take it off. Moving to her panties, I see that today they are too tight as opposed to being too loose. I tug them down, and her loli snatch is revealed. It's so plump and smooth, just like how it looks in the thousands of lolicon drawings I've collected over the years on my computer. I'm so tempted to give it a lick.. but I don't know how she'd react to that, so I restrain myself. I finish pulling the panties off her, then remove her socks. Evy now stands stark naked in front of me.
"Y-You should get in the bath now, Evy. Make sure to wash Princess Holly really good." She smiles at me, then climbs into the tub.
I turn to Riley and my heart sinks. Is she going to ask me to leave?
Riley looks at the floor and stammers "Um, c-can you stay Rei? Unless... I m-mean.. I also h-have to.. take off my clothes... Um.."
Oh god, she looks so cute all flustered like this! It's too much!
"Nono, it's fine. I d-don't mind at all. H-Here, l-let me help.."
Without thinking, I step forward and move to help Riley out of her shirt. As I grab the bottom and start to lift it, I realize what I just did and stop cold. Is she going to scream and run away!?
"Why'd you stop?" says Riley. Relief floods over me. She's really okay with this? I didn't even ask her permission first! Then I remember our first encounter: she's a very impulsive girl. This is how she acts most of the time, so why would she be upset if I act the same way?
"S-Sorry." I stammer. I finish lifting the shirt off over hear head. Her chest if completely flat, and even her upper torso has a light dusting of freckles on it. She could easily pass for a boy. Seeing how comfortable she is in front of someone she just met a day ago without a shirt on, I wondered if she has tried to get away with not wearing a shirt before... That would explain the freckles, actually.
Not wanting to wait for her to do it herself, I kneel down in front of her and grab the waistband of her shorts. I pull them down very slowly, my heart pounding as her panties come into view. To my surprise, they're bright pink and covered in unicorns and rainbows!
As if she knew exactly what I was thinking, she says "Yeah, I know... My mom bought those for me. She's always after me to wear skirts and dresses, but I refuse since I can't play sports in those, you know? So she gave up and started buying me the girliest undies she could find. I guess it was her way of not completely admitting defeat or something. Usually nobody ever sees them so I don't care, but uhh..." She stops talking for a moment, then blurts out "I j-just wanted you to know that I didn't pick these out!".
Riley blushes and looks up at the ceiling. Why would she care what I think about her undies, I wonder. I finish pulling down her shorts, and she steps out of them one leg at a time. With trembling fingers, I gently grab the lip of her undies. Glancing up at her face to see if she reacts to this, I see that she continues to stare at the ceiling, and a deep red blush is slowly creeping its way down her cheeks.
"Wh-What are you waiting f-for? T-Take them o-off..."
Very, very slowly, I begin the lower her undies. As the band passes her hips, her preteen snatch is laid bare. It's nearly as plump as her sisters, which I wouldn't have expected given her age and her athleticism. To my shock, I notice that it's also dripping wet. Is she aroused?? She's only 10 years old. I didn't know that was possible!
I finish removing her panties, and she locks her hands behind her back. She finally stops staring at the ceiling and meets my eyes. Her blush deepens and she says "I've, um... never been completely naked before in front of a boy..."
Riley looks down, and notices my massive erection. "Oh! Wh-What's that!?" she exclaims. Evy hears and looks to see what her sister is staring at. "Oh, daddy's does that too when he bathes me. I don't know what it is. What is that, Rei?"
Now it's my turn to blush as I say "It, uh... it's my pee-pee. It gets big like that when you see someone you.. love naked."
Both girls are fascinated by this. Riley asks "C-Can I see it? I've never seen a boy's pee-pee before. I've only..." She stops and blushes. When I look at her she mumbles. "Um, nothing.. C-Can I see it or not?"
Well it's only fair that I show them mine after they showed me theirs, right? I stand up and drop my pants. "It's so big!" Evy exclaims. "Huh? It's not as big as..." Riley mutters.
My penis isn't that big. Below average, actually. But I guess if neither of them have seen one before it would look big to them.
Riley leans forward and touches the tip, and my dick throbs from the contact. "Oh! It moved!" Riley exclaims. "Why'd it do that?"
"Um.. it does that when it's hard like this and you touch it. It also makes me feel really good.."
"Feel good? Does... Does that work for girls, too?" asks Riley curiously.
My heart is thudding in my chest. How far should I push this?
"Well, it's different for girls. I.. can show you if you want."
She looks curiously at me. "Ookay, what do I need to d-do?"
"First, lie down on the floor while I take off my clothes."
Blushing, Riley lies on her back on the cold tile floor. I pull my shirt off over my head, and remove my pants completely, followed by my socks. Completely naked, I kneel down besides Riley.
"Have you ever kissed a boy before?" I ask her.
"Uh, a boy in my class kissed me once." she tells me. "He told me later that his friends dared him to do it."
"Well, it's a little different like this with someone you love." Without waiting for her to say anything, I lean in and kiss her softly on the mouth. With our bodies pressed together like this, I can feel her heart is racing almost as fast as mine. I deepen the kiss, and slide my tongue into her mouth.
Okay, time for some honesty. I've never done this before. Everything I know about love making comes from watching anime and looking at naughty pictures. Even so, I still had a pretty good idea of what I needed to do.
Still kissing her, I pull her body up close to mine, until we're pressed together. Then, I grab my painfully throbbing penis and straddle it between her legs without penetrating her. Next, I slide my fingers down and rub up along her little slit until I find her little bean. I massage her little bean as I begin hot dogging her pussy, my dick sliding along her lips and out past her lithe butt.
Riley goes limp in my arms as I break the kiss, both of us gasping for air. Her breathing grows heavier as I bear down on her tiny cunny, continuing to thrust my dick between her plump thighs. A moment later, she cries out and has her first orgasm. Her body cutely twitching against mine was all I needed to see for me to finish as well. I seize her bubble butt with both hands and thrust hard between her thighs one last time, violently spraying my semen onto the tile floor next to us.
We both lie there, panting, everything else forgotten until Evy's voice breaks the silence.
"Wow, that was really neat! What was that white stuff that came out of your pee-pee, Rei?"
Realization floods over me. Oh god, what have I done!? I just hot-dogged a little girl and made her cum! I try to get ahold of myself, and clear my throat.
"Y-Yeah, so that's one way to d-do it." I stammer.
Riley sits up and looks at me. "Th-That felt... AMAZING!~" she says far too loudly for my liking. "Can we do it again!?"
What? She doesn't understand what I just did. This is really bad, I have to fix this!
"Um Riley... I shouldn't have done that. I got carried away. This is not something you're supposed to do with.. with children..."
She looks confused. "Why not? It felt so gooood..!~"
I wet my dry lips with my tongue. I have to play this just right...
"B-Because it's not allowed. I would go to jail if anyone found out. My life would be ruined forever."
Riley looks shocked. "WHAT!? But... why!? You didn't do anything wrong!"
"I know that, but... You see, most people don't think like we do. They have... weird ideas of who can love who. It's really dumb, but that's the way it is..."
"B-But I asked you to do it!" Riley says. "Doesn't that matter!?"
"No, it doesn't. Not to most people. They would still blame me."
"But thats stupid!" she cries. "Yeah!" Evy joins in. "That's really dumb!"
"Well it doesn't matter what we think." I say. "You have to promise not to tell anyone about this, not even your parents!"
The two girls look at each other. "We promise..." Riley looks sad. "Does that mean we can't do it again...?"
I quickly tell them: "I never said that. I just wanted to make sure you understood how serious this is."
"Oh, okay." says Riley. "Can we do it again now?"
I laugh and tell her "Actually, boys can't do it again right away. Why don't you have your bath, then we'll talk."
Riley grins "Okay!~". She hops up and leaps into the tub, splashing me with water. "Careful!" I exclaim.
Evy looks at me and says "But I wanted to try it too..." She pouts so fucking cutely that it's almost enough to get my dick up again, but I still need a minute.
I glance at the clock. Crap, it's almost 7PM! "Your parents will be home soon, we need to hurry. Evy, we can try it tomorrow, I promise. Remember what I said about not telling anyone!"
I hurriedly scrub both girls, regretting not being able to take the time to enjoy washing two naked little girls at once. They get out of the tub and I dry them off, then help them both to redress. We go downstairs and outside. Somehow Tera is STILL skipping on the driveway. Man, that girl really loves to skip!
I kneel down between both girls and put an arm on each of their shoulders, then whisper to them "Remember what I said, you can't tell anyone what we did." They nod their acknowledgment, then I straighten up and call out to Tera.
"Tera! It's time to go home. Your parents will be home soon and they asked me to put your dinner in the oven 15 minutes before they got home, so lets go!"
Without a word, Tera skips on over to us, and I lead both girls back to their house.
I turn on the TV for the kids to watch and put their dinner in the oven. When I turn around, Tera is standing there.
"What happened today?" she asks me. "Evy won't tell me and Riley just keeps saying 'later'..."
"Evy got picked on by some bullies. Riley saw and beat them up."
Tera smirks when she hears this. "Oh I wish I was there to see that!"
"But then why was Riley so sad?"
"She thought she'd done a bad thing. I explained to her that she was protecting her little sister, and that she was very brave."
"I don't know why she fusses so much about that kind of stuff." Tera huffs. "Those bullies deserve worse than they got, picking on poor Evy like that!"
"Well, it's all in the past now. C'mon, let's go watch some TV."
She smiles and skips back to the den, plopping onto the couch. I shake my head and go to join her.
...
When Laura and Mike come home, they fuss over Evy, who after all that happened earlier had completely forgotten about her black eye. She mutters that it really doesn't hurt that much, but that doesn't stop them. Her mom says she's going to call the school first thing in the morning and give them an earful for letting this happen on school grounds. They both thank me over and over again for taking care of Evy, and insist on paying me more than five times what we'd agreed on.
When I try to say goodnight and leave, all three girls insist on saying goodbye to me with big hugs. After that, Mike tells them to go get ready for bed. Once all three girls are upstairs, they pull me aside.
"Wow Rei, our girls have really taken to you, huh?" says Laura. "I can't believe how lucky we got having someone like you as a neighbor." Mike adds. "Anytime you want to spend some time with our girls, just come on over. We've had to move around way too much because of both of our jobs, and as a result they've all become somewhat isolated in their own ways. Having someone like you around is really going to help them open up and learn how to make friends".
I blush and thank them for the compliment, then tell them goodnight and leave. After the door closes, I hang my head in shame. If they really knew... they wouldn't be saying any of those nice things to me.
...
That night, I lie awake in bed worrying. Will they tell anyone what we did? I doubt Riley will, she's much older and seemed genuinely appalled at the thought that she could in any way be responsible for ruining my life. But Evy... she's quite young. I don't know if she will tell... Then again, she's so quiet. Her mom says she barely talks to anyone. She's closest to Riley, and it won't matter if they talk about it to each other...
I thrash for a while thinking these thoughts, before eventually falling into an uneasy slumber...
Chapter IV