Lilly and Anna both climbed out of the car with apprehension. Anna hoped their father would just let them be when they got home, but she knew he probably wouldn’t. He had already said that their mother was out of town again. While Lilly didn’t know what that really meant quite yet, Anna did.
Every time their mother went out of town for business, their father had always managed to find time alone with Anna. Now that they wouldn’t have to keep a secret from Lilly anymore, Anna worried that he would do even more.
“Alright, in the bath, kids.” Their father called to them when they arrived home and ran in from the garage. Today would be one for the record books, he thought to himself as the girls ran off towards the bathroom. His youngest had given her very first blow job and unbeknownst to her, Anna was going to give up another one of her firsts today, too.
In the bathroom, Anna helped Lilly out of her dress that now stained down the front with their father’s cum. She then turned to warm up the water before stripping off her leotard. By the time their father walked in to check on them, the two girls were already in the water and Anna had washed most of the dried cum off Lilly’s cheek.
“You two are such great little girls,” he complemented them. “Go ahead and get ready for bed early when you’re done and dinner should be ready by then. Afterwards, we can pick out a movie and have some kettle corn!”
“Yay, I love kettle corn” Lilly said excitedly. Her little sister’s excited tone made Anna hopeful that they really would just have a normal movie night with their father. She clung to that hope as the girls finished bathing.
When they were done, the two girls dried off and dressed in their pajamas as instructed. Lilly usually wore one of their father’s shirts to bed. It fit much like a dress on her, but the hole were her head stuck out was far too big and frequently fell off of one shoulder. Anna on the other hand, wore a set of pink pajamas with unicorns all over the pants. The matching shirt was white with pink sleeves and had one larger unicorn right in the center of her chest. Once they were dressed, they both made their way to the kitchen where their dinner was almost ready.
Their father was quite a good cook and had enjoyed experimenting with food almost as much as experimenting with his little girls. As a result, they ate well that night. The pear glazed pork chops were cooked perfectly and neither girl complained about the perfectly seasoned asparagus and mashed potatoes and gravy on the side.
After dinner, the girls picked out a movie and once the dishes were clean, their father joined them in the family room. Both girls were a bit apprehensive when he suggested they all share the big chair, but they both joined him on his lap regardless.
At first, it seemed as though they really would just watch a move on his lap. As the film progressed however, he beg to slowly slide his hand up Lilly’s bare leg.
“Hey!” She called out when he started pushing up the bottom of her nightshirt.
“Shhh…just enjoy the movie, sweetie,” he said as his hand slid up further. By then, Anna was aware of what was happening and watched Lilly squirm out of the corner of her eye when he touched her panties. Then, she suddenly felt a hand sliding up her shirt, too. Their father stuffed his hand into Lilly’s panties, causing her to squirm further. Anna was similarly treated to his free hand rubbing her nipples underneath her shirt.
His finger steadily toyed with Lilly’s cunt as she tried to focus on the T.V. While the movie may not have nearing its climax yet, Lilly was. Anna watched apprehensively as Lilly squirmed on the other side of the chair, making cute squeals as she did.
Once Lilly had cum, her father turned his attention back towards Anna. With his other hand now free, he pulled her pajama top up past her nipples and then completely over her head before returning to to rub her chest. Then, he leaned in to kiss her neck.
“I think it’s time we take this to the bedroom,” he muttered as he smelled Anna’s freshly shampooed hair.
“But the move isn’t over yet,” Lilly complained,
“Oh, That’s okay,” he answered. “You can finish it when we’re done. I have something else I want you to watch. He nudged Lilly out of the chair and pushed Anna up as well. Her shirt, which had been on her lap, fell to the floor. She knew better than to reach for it.
He grabbed both girl’s hands and led them to the master bedroom, “This will be a lot of fun!” He exclaimed.” Although, he failed to mention who it would be fun for…
“Here, sit right in the edge there, Lilly,” he pointed to one side of their parent’s large bed. She hopped up, nervously, but her movements still reeked of innocence. Anna was visibly apprehensive when he guided her to lay down in the center of the bed. She flinched when he started touching her again, this time putting a finger into either side of her bottoms and pulling them off. He dropped them onto the floor of the room and then slowly started to take off his own clothes.
While she had seen her father strip many times before, something about him that night seemed different. She watched nervously as he carefully undid his trousers and dropped them down. Then as he revealed his chest, one button at a time. Only once we was wearing nothing but his white briefs, did he return to the bed.
He was incredibly horny but despite that, their father took his time. He kissed Lilly on the forehead before turning to Anna and planting a kiss right on her lips. His hands continued feeling her bare skin, reminding her that he was going to do whatever he wanted as usual. After a few minutes of kissing and rubbing up and down her chest, a hand went into her panties and began pulling them down. He quickly removed his briefs, too and paused to admire his eldest daughter.
Her hair strewn lazily around the pillow and her face was largely expressionless. He looked lower to her flat chest. Then he admired her stomach as it rose and fell with each breath. Her pussy was cute and innocent, too. He leaned down and planted a kiss right on her virgin slit, giving it a gentle lick when he did.
Still taking if slow, he kissed his way up Anna’s flat chest, to her neck, and then to her lips. She felt his erection rub the inside of her leg as their lips touched. Then—he reposition himself just slightly.
“No!” She looked down with concern when she felt his cock at the entrance to her cunt. She just realized in that moment what he wanted to do.
“It’s okay sweetie, I’ll take it slow,” he consoled her. “Let’s show your little sister what a big girl you are. Sitting on her knees to the side of the bed, Lilly was still watching, nightshirt hanging off one shoulder. Her expression showed signs of boredom. But it was about to get a lot more exciting. She watched their father push her big sister’s legs apart, preparing her for what was about to come next.
Anna gasped when she felt her father’s cock press into her. The nine year old grunted and arched her back in response under the pressure.
“That’s it princess,” her father grabbed her and pulled her closer. Then he pushed his cock fully inside, taking her virginity.
“Owwww!” Anna cried out, increasing in pitch as he pushed in further. “Daddy, stawp!” Lilly was a bit concerned now, but could do nothing to help.
“It’s okay, daddy loves you,” he replied. “You’re doing such a great job. Just be brave for your sister, okay?” He leaned in and kissed her as a few tears began to fall.
“Pretty little girl,” he consoled her. “Don’t cry, sweetie. Your sister and I both love you so much!” He began slowly moving in and out of her. She whined again as he continued to fuck her, feeling her father’s cock sliding inside her and his body rubbing against hers.
“That’s it, baby,” he moaned. “You’re doing so good.” He continued his steady movements in and out of the girl. She wiped a tear from her eyes, looking over at Lilly who looked as though she might cry, too.
Anna suddenly felt her father pick up the pace and she began to panic when she felt him continue to invade her body with more force.
“Don’t worry, daddy’s here with you. Daddy loves you.” was his response when she let out a few more cries. She gasped when he pushed his way in as far as he could, but that was the beginning of the end.
He moaned as he came inside Anna for the first time, no longer thrusting, just laying on top of her and filling her with his cum. Her body was still tense, though and only fully relaxed when he was through and pulled his cock out of her.
“Its okay, Anna,” her father said, seeing her wipe another tear from her eye. “You did a great job, didn’t she, Lilly?”
“Yes,” Lilly replied quietly. She had no idea what doing a good job meant, but simply agreed with their father. Anna wasn’t calmed by the assurances.
“Your first time can be tough, why don’t you give your sister a hug to help her feel better?” He suggested to the five year old. Lilly leaned in and hugged Anna, who hugged her little sister back, but said nothing. As if she were a teddy bear, Anna held on tightly to her sister for comfort. Meanwhile between her legs, she felt warm cum begin to drip out of her pussy as their father left the room.
Both girls laid together for several minutes while they recovered. “Let’s go finish that movie,” Anna finally piped up.
“Okay,” Lilly started to get up. Anna was still trying to come to terms with her feelings. And it didn’t help that she was a little sore from her father’s repetitive thrusting into her cunt. Regardless, she pulled herself together as best as she could.
Picking her pajama bottoms and panties up off the floor, she dressed as she headed back to the family room where their movie was still paused.
Their father, no longer interested in movie night, had retired instead to his home office. With some time to themselves, Anna and Lilly settled into the large comfy rocking chair together.
Anna felt dejected as she hit play on the remote. She felt a bit her father’s cum leaking into her panties while she sat with her sister. But together, the two of them became engrossed in their movie and did their best to put their conflicted feelings behind them.