Offline/Add a dare punishment for Nicole
"Actually, strip AND a dare," you suggest. "I don't think stripping is enough of a punishment if you cheat."
"Good point!" Hannah smirks at you and nods. "Definitely needs a dare too."
"I cheated? How did I cheat!" Nicole pouts somewhat playfully, but is really disappointed that she somehow lost. "I really tried to think of something no one had done!"
Hannah shakes her head with condescension. "Duh. That's the problem. You can't just say stuff like "I've never jumped into a volcano" because obviously no one has." Hannah has a point, kinda. It doesn't at all surprise you that she'd want to come up with new rules. She probably only did this to strip Nicky faster (and you should thank her later) but you want to get more dares going too. Thankfully Hannah is so smooth its as if that was her intention all along. "You can't cheat the game or the punishment gets flipped. So now YOU strip... and we get to give you a dare."
Nicole is hard pressed to contest the logic of Hannah's argument. She's also a good sport, so she sighs, stands, and undoes her shorts. It's very clear that she's anxious about being the first to take something off of any real consequence, which is funny considering how long you all spent this morning in your undies, but she pushes through her nerves. "Promise this isn't just a 'pick on Nicole' game, right?"
Hannah smiles. "Promise! I'll make sure you have lots of fun!"
"What dare are we giving her?" you ask as casually as you can, belying your interest. You then note, "It does have to be fun."
Jet makes a clicking sound while watching Nicole slide her jean shorts off to reveal white panties. "If she secretly has a thing for horses... Let's make her act like one."
"That's perfect!" approves Hannah. "I'd love to give the little horsey a few spanks while she neighs for us!"
"Yeah! Me too!" you chuckle, quick to place yourself in line. Jet just laughs at you and nods.
"Awesome! Okay, Nicole?" Hannah sings out to Nicky, as if she's not sitting a few feet away listening to this. "You have to walk around on all fours like a good pony and let each of us spank you! Kay?"
Nicole tries to frown but she's already smiling. She can't hide that she's at least amused by this. But when she starts off you can see why she might think this is even funnier than it already is. Lifting her head, straightening her haunches, and trotting forward like the proud little filly she was born to be, you see the word "WHAM" printed on the back of her panties comic book style, partly covered by the hem of her shirt. Her panties don't just have a target on them, they almost have instructions.
"Holy shit! She's actually practiced this! I fucking knew it too!" Jet cries with a laugh. "Horse girl, 100%!"
Nicole trots in a tight circle in the middle of the cabin, showing off her trim little pony form. After stopping in front of you she stomps one of her front hoofs and gives a convincing whinny followed by a whip of her long ponytail as she looks toward you. After you throw a light spank she looks away, looks back, and stomps again dissatisfied. You happily give her tight rear end a firm slap which sends her trotting again with another whinny.
Several fast spanks are levied by Hannah as Nicole trots by, yelling out "Wham!" each time. The filly briefly quickens her pace around the room whenever a hand connects with her. You assumed she would stop after everyone had a turn, but Nicole keeps trotting, looking for more, and you throw as many on you can on each pass to try to satisfy her. Hannah grabs hold of Nicky to land a more dramatic slap before Nicole crawls forward to a full stop in front of Jet, giving him his own opportunity for the same. Jet actually pushes the hem of Nicole's shirt up her back this time so that her entire pantied ass is in plain view, placing a hand on the bare skin around her waist to hold her in place.
"You two pansies don't know how to smack a horse. You gotta show 'em you mean business."
Jet's first two smacks are square on the WHAM but they're just warm ups. The next has some weight behind it and Nicole's back curves up a little after it lands. She gasps and shifts her legs but doesn't trot away. Maybe that's because Jet's hand keeps her in place. This includes him keeping her back pressed down to ensure her ass is pushed out behind her before he throws another healthy slap against one of her cheeks. He aims for the other side with a big wind up just as Hannah darts in and yanks down on the back of Nicole's full-bottomed panties.
"NeeigHEY!" yelps Nicole.
Jet's hand lands on bare flesh which you watch ripple in slow motion, her compact backside overwhelmed by his hefty palm. This solid smack of her ass has a satisfying sound to it, skin on skin, and the surprised yelp from Nicole just makes it better. All four of you laugh at the unexpected sound of a raw bottomed spanking but Nicole just drops her head with embarrassment, allowing her cousin to continue. Jet throws a few more light smacks just to milk it before he stops himself.
You notice Nicole has a weird grin when Jet stops. She quickly rights herself afterward to put her underwear back into place, but she totally let him spank her bare ass before that. She's blushing pretty hard. "Okay, you got me, geez..."
Hannah laughs as she is shoved by Jet for making him touch his cousin's ass. He's really broken up about it (not). Nicole crawls back over to her seat beside you. Jet does apologize, half-heartedly, but Nicole says it's fine.
"Jay is a better spanker anyway," Nicole adds, as some sort of weird jab at the couple across the room.
Hannah waves her hands in front of her, still tickled about her prank on Nicole, but trying to move on. "Okay, okay, Nicole did her punishment. Back to normal now. Let's go."
Jet, now getting into this odd little game, first looks Nicole up and down and then turns to his girlfriend. He states, while smiling straight at Hannah, "Never have I ever inserted something into my body."
Hannah scoffs. "Yeah. Well, duh. Of course I have! Like, lots!" She yanks off her second sock then looks across at Nicole with amusement as the younger girl starts tugging her t-shirt up her body.
"Wait, Nicky? Really? Look at you, naughty little Nicky! You're not as innocent as you look! Okay, wait... but not just your fingers?" Nicole pauses and shakes her head. "What have you used?"
"My toothbrush," she says flatly. That makes all of you question her at once.
"Uh, Nicole, I wasn't talking about brushing your teeth," explains Jet.
"Yeah. Neither am I." Nicole has a hint of a grin on her face while trying to deliver that line as coolly as possible.
The daring girl confidently tosses her shirt to the side as both Hannah and Jet exclaim "oh shit" and "yeet", but confident naughty Nicky is far from naked. She is wearing a plain white undershirt under her t-shirt, same as yesterday, and has two pairs of shoulder straps indicating a training bra of some kind. So she's hardly worse off than she was. Still, having her sitting here in her underthings yet again draws your attention just as much as her swimsuit, if not more so, as you try to come up with something for your turn.