Offline/Encourage Nicole to try to take Jet
With Hannah being so intimidating you feel you have to help push this along.
"It's just sex," you poke Nicole, trying to minimize things. "But this... isn't, right? Just see what you can do."
Hannah smiles and nods then returns to her corner leaving Nicole to act on her own free will, at least for the moment. Turns out Nicole does want some control of her destiny though, despite her predisposition for passivity. It doesn't take long before she starts inching toward Jet, but she's still running this all through her head as she makes her way over.
"This is... it's um... my first time," she manages to get out. "Or maybe it isn't? I dunno..." She clearly feels this is a big deal, even if the others don't.
"Yeah? All good. Gotta start sometime. I was Hannah's first too," offers Jet. Somehow you find that hard to believe, although Hannah tries to shush him, as if he just broke some power she held over the room.
"You're not going to tell anyone though, right? That we did this?"
"Tell them what? That my cousin test-fit my dick?" Nicole's lips thin as her concern grows. Jet just chuckles. "Oh yeah, I'll totally tell. Let's take pictures too. I'll tell Uncle Dave, then Aunt Grace, then-" Jet chuckles some more as Nicole scrunches her face up behind her glasses, trying not to laugh. She slaps his chest as he keeps rambling about all the family he's going to describe her pussy to. Jet just laughs and gives a playful shove back.
"Well I'm telling you to hurry up," mutters Hannah quietly. You heard her, but you doubt the others did.
On her knees next to Jet, Nicole openly stares at the magnificent cock before her. "I still don't, um... J-just in case, is there... protection? Like, you know... I guess... a condom?"
Jet nods and shrugs. "Oh, yeah, we-"
"SORRY!" shouts Hannah, startling everyone. She composes herself quickly. "We're fresh out! But don't worry! It's not like you can get pregnant or anything."
"How come? I'm pretty sure I could... " Nicole quietly adds, "If we really did it I mean..."
Hannah scoffs. "God, you're so young. Do you even know how it works? You haven't had a period yet! So there's-"
"Yeah, I have."
"No way! God, such a liar!" scoffs Hannah again dismissively. "You'll be fine! You're just sticking it in anyway. A condom would only make it tighter, which you probably don't need."
Jet puts his hand on Nicole's hip for reassurance then looks over to his girlfriend. "Hannah, I thought we ha-"
"Have I ever told you..." interrupts Hannah. "How much I've fantasized eating your cum out of another girl's pussy? I mean, I've never gone down on a girl before. But when I do, I want you to be leaking out of her, coating my tongue, flooding my mouth..."
Jet stares at Hannah for a moment, a little incredulous. She's nearly kissing him, but not quite. You notice his dick bob and flex. Hannah stares back and licks her lips. Jet doesn't stand a chance here. "Yeah! Damn, cuzzie! Sorry 'bout that. No condoms."
"Seriously, you're not even 'doing it', so chill, you don't need one," adds Hannah. "But even if you were, you can't get pregnant your first time. That's, like, science or something."
Nicole surely doesn't believe that, but she may have just been bullied into accepting it. In fact she charges forward, perhaps before she loses her resolve. She stretches one leg across both of Jet's to straddle him while he's still propped up against the wall. Dropping to a low squat like she tried out a few minutes ago, she reaches down and grabs hold of his dick, finally holding a penis for the first time despite already grinding two. She handles it cautiously, like it could bite her at any moment, and moves it all around just to make sure it doesn't suddenly attack. But then she pulls it closer, lining up his fat head with her crotch, still rosy pink, wet, excited.
"Okay. We're just... trying," she says out loud to herself, building her confidence. "I can fit this..."
You don't have a great angle anymore, so you quickly shuffle over to Nicole's spot hoping to get a better view. There's no need to be quick though as Nicole is taking her time with it. She rubs Jet's bulbous tip through her lips over and over, longer than a simple warm up, and for good reason. This is her last chance to change her mind. But she can't. Jet doesn't let her.
Maybe he was growing impatient, but watching and waiting to time it perfectly, Jet flexes his butt at just the right moment to push the head of his cock just past Nicole's lips into her entrance. She gasps in shock but after a few seconds leads him in a tiny bit deeper on her own, slowly lowering herself down. Jet's knob splits her wide before it slips out of sight, but that's just his tip which isn't very much considering his impressive length.
"Shit, Nicky. You're tight as hell. I mean, Hannah is tight too, but... goddamn."
Nicole doesn't reply. Instead, since she can't turn back now, she tries to force herself down another inch. Jet steadies himself but lets her continue at her own pace. Their age difference is pretty stark now that she's trying to sit on his dick proper. She just looks so tiny, this skinny little girl with glasses and ponytail getting impaled atop a high school senior's porn star cock. It's almost comical really, like he's only letting her try because he knows she can't.
Hannah sprawls out into the middle of the small cabin on her stomach, leaning over one of Jet's legs to peer up at Nicole's underside from behind. "Wow. Yeah. That's hot." Hannah looks at you with a smirk when she says this, which only piques your curiosity.
Essentially invited, you also slide onto Hannah's sleeping bag behind your cousin, leaning over Jet's other leg. Looking up from underneath her, Nicole's pussy lips seem to grip Jet's shaft so tightly that they fold back in on themselves as she pushes down. Despite how obviously wet she still is from before, she can't get him in. Struggling, she lifts up a tiny bit then tries to go down again, forcing whatever tiny gains she can as she grunts and gasps her way lower, but making little progress. The outside of her pussy gets dragged inside her vagina by Jet's thick dick every time, making her invitingly smooth mound even more featureless.
Hannah reaches out and fingers the edge between Jet's dick and Nicole's pussy. Nicole looks back over her shoulder, only now noticing where you and Hannah have decided to position yourselves. Embarrassed, Nicole throws a hand up to cover one side of her face. "Guys, c'mon. That's embarrassing. This is hard enough."
"Yeah, it looks hard," you note, staring at the cock splitting open your cousin.
"He sure is! And it's sooo hot. You're doing great!"
Nicole shifts a leg wider, twists to one side, and whimpers her frustration. "He just doesn't fit!"
"Then make him fit." Hannah replies tersely, like Nicole is the dumbest girl alive. But then her singsong voice bounces back. "Vayjay's are way stretchy. Just push through it!"
"I dunno, babe. She's kinda... stuck," notes Jet.
"Oh my god," sighs Hannah, shuffling closer and pulling her legs underneath her. "Fine. Ease up a little Nicky."
Nicole leans forward, rising slowly. Jet is quick to grab onto her sides to stop her ascent, clearly not wanting her to come off all the way. You can just barely see the glistening ridge of Jet's cock appear outside Nicole's straining pussy as the edges of her small inner lips come back into view.
Hannah reaches in again, this time with both hands, and thumbs either side of Nicole's pussy. She strains to stretch Nicole's vulva any wider but is able to pin them down under her thumbs. "Okay, I'll hold you open. Now you should just slide down!"
Nicole descends again, and again seems to get stuck on Jet's cock, despite Hannah's assistance. But then Jet decides to help. He presses down on Nicole's scant hips and forces her onto him.
"Wai-AHHH!" she shouts as Jet suddenly becomes 'unstuck' and forces Nicole down a solid 2 or 3 inches of cock. Nicole buckles forward, grimacing and gasping.
"Yeaaah. That feels better," sighs Jet.
"Ohmygawd, I felt that!" shares Hannah, releasing her grip only to rub excitedly along Nicole's inseam. "Did we just do that? We did, right? We totally just popped her cherry!" Interesting that she wants to take some credit for that. Jet definitely did the popping.
Jet lets Nicole up a little then forces her down again. He does this a few times, mechanically and methodically moving Nicole up and down his dick, using her like a doll, seemingly just to prove that she's not broken.
"You alright?" he asks, only a little concerned.
"I gyuh-guess..." grunts Nicole. "I'm okay."
"Was that not the hottest fucking thing?" Hannah asks, pulling back beside you.
"Uh, yeah," you stutter. It was really hot. You just wish your dick was the one that accomplished that feat.
Nicole plants her hands on Jet's shoulders and lifts herself higher to gather her senses without Jet's help. Then, taking a breath, she slides down on her own, slowly, experimentally, taking him in inch by inch. Despite her careful journey downward, she isn't able to make it anywhere near the bottom before she has to stop, letting out the deep breath she was holding with a whimpery moan.
"Goddamn cousie, you're still real fuckin tight."
"You're really... big," she replies. "But we'll... get it in."
"Ugh. You little slut! I love it!" After a quick spank of Nicole's butt, Hannah reaches under Nicole again, this time grabbing hold of the exposed half of Jet's shaft. "And Jet! You're crazy hard!" She turns to you, the brightest smile on her face. "Seriously! This is the stiffest cock you'll ever feel."