Talk:Disciplinary Action/Disciplinary Office/First Quarter/New Policy/Melany/Punish/Show

Hmm, it seems Marcus wanted to experiment with Melany and do to her, what he did to his mother. However his mom didn't bleed when he fucked her, so that's probably why it didn't progress any further before they got caught. --MrPib (talk) 13:40, 26 May 2022 (CEST)

Plausible, and would mean Ms. Curtis was actually right and they were having sex, so knocking the little girl up is totally an option.--Notsooldpervert (talk) 21:23, 26 May 2022 (CEST)

You know, I was thinking, we need to play this smoothly. If we fuck Melany's brains out and leave her full of our seed, that would cause a rift between the MC and his sister; but it would also technically be a waste of valuable resources. Why give a pregnancy risk to a child that, to the town's knowledge, isn't currently fertile? If she can't get pregnant, then there's no "risk". Depending on who instigated (all signs point to Marcus, knowing what happened in week 1), we could let Melany off with an external ejaculation. We would also have to fill in our sister as to why we decided on this punishment.

We can call our sister down, inform her of the catalyst (events from week 1, informing her about Marcus and Chester), blindfold Melany, do something sexual with our sister, remove Melany's blindfold and then cum on the outside of Melany's slit and then clean her up. --MrPib (talk) 21:40, 27 May 2022 (CEST)

Why would it cause a rift with the MC's sister? It's not her kid, and if she gets in trouble, she gets in trouble. With the school Doc's experiment, Melany will be fertile sooner rather than later. --Notsooldpervert (talk) 21:50, 27 May 2022 (CEST)

While it may not be one of her biological children, Melany is still one of her students, iirc this is the first time we dole out such a large punishment for one of her students. (remember that Chester and Marcus were punished in week 1 on the down low, no one knows that they committed incest, besides the MC and their mothers)

Now, the only people that know that Melany would potentially be fertile, would be the MC and Dr. Hartnell. Yes the guidelines are in our favor and we have every right to creampie Melany, but if we play the long con of befriending people, we can gain allies.

An example would be Ms. Varano and Mrs. Walton, we could offer to have sex with them so that if they did wind up pregnant, they could just say that the MC is the father of the child and completely avoid the repercussions of incest. What is more damaging to the women's reputations, an adulterous baby as part of the sanctioned punishments, or an incest baby? By giving the women this option, it appears that we care for them and they will begin to trust us.

By not giving Melany a pregnancy risk, not only do we save face with our sister, but we also gain credibility that we take the job seriously, as it would be a waste to attempt to impregnate a girl that isn't fertile yet. (remember that the town doesn't know that Melany is fertile) --MrPib (talk) 22:10, 27 May 2022 (CEST)

True. Technically if they were actually having sex, wouldn't the guideline punishment be guaranteed impregnation? Regardless, you have a point of making allies, and by keeping little Melany from getting knocked up, you would definitely win points with Mrs. Varano, and have a reason to get Mrs. Walton involved again. In addition to getting them to have sex with the MC to help cover the mother's incest punishment, we could also bring them in to help punish boys with more public punishments as a way to muddy the waters, so to speak, over who the father of their babies is. Speaking of Mrs. Varano, I really hope someone gets around to the story line where she fabricates the need for a punishment for her own daughter, solely for the purpose of helping him fuck her full of cum. --Notsooldpervert (talk) 00:55, 28 May 2022 (CEST)

"Forced Impregnation" is not the only Extreme Punishment. Ms. Varano told us to use our own Judgement. So, since Marcus was the instigator, we can frame it as "rape" and because she shouldn't be fertile at her age, a deep creampie is a waste. and if we read the extreme guidelines,

Non-penetrative and non-pregnancy risking versions of this punishment may be an option for a severe punishment or even a high-level moderate punishment in the case of a girl grade 3 or younger. 

suffice to say, cumming on her belly or against her slit would be enough. --MrPib (talk) 02:55, 28 May 2022 (CEST)

That one you clipped out of the extreme punishment guidelines was saying that the "share punishment administrator's bed" punishment can also be used in response to a moderate infraction for girls age 3 and younger, or for a severe infraction for girls older than that, so long as it doesn't involve a pregnancy risk. It is not saying that there are extreme punishment options that don't involve pregnancy risk. Jemini (talk) 20:39, 28 May 2022 (CEST)